Abstract:This a particularly exciting time for gravitational wave physics. Ground-based gravitational wave detectors are now operating at a sensitivity such that gravitational radiation may soon be directly detected, and recently several groups have independently made significant breakthroughs that have finally enabled numerical relativists to solve the Einstein field equations for coalescing black-hole binaries, a key source of gravitational radiation. The numerical relativity community is now in the position to begin providing simulated merger waveforms for use by the data analysis community, and it is therefore very important that we provide ways to validate the results produced by various numerical approaches. Here, we present a simple comparison of the waveforms produced by two very different, but equally successful approaches--the generalized harmonic gauge and the moving puncture methods. We compare waveforms of equal-mass black hole mergers with minimal or vanishing spins. The results show exceptional agreement for the final burst of radiation, with some differences attributable to small spins on the black holes in one case.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the problem of comparing gravitational - wave waveforms generated during the merger of black - hole binaries. Specifically, the paper verifies the validity and accuracy of these methods by comparing waveforms obtained by different research teams using different numerical methods. These methods include the generalized harmonic gauge and the moving puncture method. The paper focuses on waveforms during the merger of equal - mass black holes with minimal or no spin, with particular emphasis on the high consistency in the radiation burst part at the end of the merger, as well as some differences due to the small spin of a black hole in one case. ### Main problems and goals 1. **Verify the accuracy of numerical simulations**: Verify the reliability and accuracy of each method by comparing the simulation results of different research teams. 2. **Evaluate the influence of initial data**: Explore the influence of different initial data models on the final waveform results. 3. **Analyze the consistency of waveforms**: In particular, whether the waveforms obtained by different methods are consistent in the radiation burst part at the end of the merger. 4. **Identify potential errors**: Evaluate the magnitude of numerical errors by comparing simulation results at different resolutions. ### Research background - **Development of gravitational - wave detectors**: Current ground - based gravitational - wave detectors (such as LIGO) have reached the sensitivity to detect gravitational waves. - **Breakthroughs in numerical relativity**: Multiple research teams have made important progress in solving Einstein's field equations and are able to simulate the entire process of black - hole binary mergers. - **Importance of waveform prediction**: Accurate waveform prediction helps to improve the ability to identify signals from noise, thereby increasing the probability of detecting gravitational waves. ### Methods and results - **Different numerical methods**: - **Generalized harmonic gauge**: Used by the Pretorius team, employing the constraint damping technique. - **Moving puncture method**: Used by the UTB and GSFC teams, based on the BSSN equation system. - **Initial data models**: - The Pretorius team uses the Cook - Pfeiffer technique to generate quasi - circular orbit data. - The UTB and GSFC teams use the Brandt - Brügmann puncture method to generate initial data. - **Waveform extraction**: - Each team uses different coordinate systems and extraction radii to extract waveform information. - Evaluate the error level by comparing waveforms extracted at different distances. ### Conclusions - **Consistency of waveforms at the end of the merger**: The waveforms at the end of the merger obtained by different methods are highly consistent, especially in the radiation burst part. - **Influence of initial data**: Small differences in initial data have a certain influence on the waveform results, but overall do not affect the waveform characteristics at the end of the merger. - **Spin effect**: In the Pretorius team's simulation, the black hole has a small spin, resulting in a slightly higher waveform frequency. - **Control of numerical errors**: Each team effectively controls numerical errors through multi - resolution simulations and comparison of different extraction radii. In conclusion, through detailed comparison and analysis, this paper demonstrates the reliability and consistency of different numerical methods in simulating the process of black - hole binary mergers, providing an important reference for future gravitational - wave data analysis.

Comparisons of binary black hole merger waveforms

Enriching the Symphony of Gravitational Waves from Binary Black Holes by Tuning Higher Harmonics

Binary Black Hole Coalescence Phenomenology from Numerical Relativity

Insights into Binary Neutron Star Merger Simulations: A Multi-Code Comparison

Simulating binary black hole mergers using discontinuous Galerkin methods

Black hole - neutron star binaries with high spins and large mass asymmetries: II. Properties of dynamical simulations

Numerical-relativity simulations of the quasi-circular inspiral and merger of non-spinning, charged black holes: methods and comparison with approximate approaches

Comparing Numerical Relativity and Perturbation Theory Waveforms for a Non-Spinning Equal-Mass Binary

A phenomenological gravitational waveform model of binary black holes incorporating horizon fluxes

Improved methods for simulating nearly extremal binary black holes

Comparing gravitational waveform models for binary black hole mergers through a hypermodels approach

Machine Learning Gravitational Waves from Binary Black Hole Mergers

Unveiling the Merger Structure of Black Hole Binaries in Generic Planar Orbits

General Relativistic Simulations of High-Mass Binary Neutron Star Mergers: rapid formation of low-mass stellar black holes

Post-merger gravitational-wave signal from neutron-star binaries: a new look at an old problem

Binary Black Hole Waveforms from High-Resolution GR-Athena++ Simulations

An eccentric binary blackhole in post-Newtonian theory

Unraveling information about supranuclear-dense matter from the complete binary neutron star coalescence process using future gravitational-wave detector networks