Abstract:We conduct a thorough Bayesian analysis of the possibility that the black hole merger events seen in gravitational waves are primordial black hole (PBH) mergers. Using the latest merger rate models for PBH binaries drawn from a lognormal mass function we compute posterior parameter constraints and Bayesian evidences using data from the first two observing runs of LIGO-Virgo. We account for theoretical uncertainty due to possible disruption of the binary by surrounding PBHs, which can suppress the merger rate significantly. We also consider simple astrophysically motivated models and find that these are favoured decisively over the PBH scenario, quantified by the Bayesian evidence ratio. Paying careful attention to the influence of the parameter priors and the quality of the model fits, we show that the evidence ratios can be understood by comparing the predicted chirp mass distribution to that of the data. We identify the posterior predictive distribution of chirp mass as a vital tool for discriminating between models. A model in which all mergers are PBH binaries is strongly disfavoured compared with astrophysical models, in part due to the over-prediction of heavy systems having $\mathcal{M}_{\rm chirp} \gtrsim 40 \, M_\odot$ and positive skewness over the range of observed masses which does not match the observations. We find that the fit is not significantly improved by adding a maximum mass cut-off, a bimodal mass function, or imposing that PBH binaries form at late times. We argue that a successful PBH model must either modify the lognormal shape of the initial mass function significantly or abandon the hypothesis that all observed merging binaries are primordial. We develop and apply techniques for analysing PBH models with gravitational wave data which will be necessary for robust statistical inference as the gravitational wave source sample size increases.

Confronting the primordial black hole scenario with the gravitational-wave events detected by LIGO-Virgo

Primordial black hole interpretation in subsolar mass gravitational wave candidate SSM200308

Confronting primordial black holes with LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA and the Einstein Telescope

Constraints on primordial-black-hole population and cosmic expansion history from GWTC-3

Constraints on the Primordial Black Hole Abundance through Scalar-Induced Gravitational Waves from Advanced LIGO and Virgo's First Three Observing Runs

When Primordial Black Holes from Sound Speed Resonance Meet a Stochastic Background of Gravitational Waves

GW230529_181500: a potential primordial binary black hole merger in the mass gap

Probing Primordial Black Hole Scenarios with Terrestrial Gravitational Wave Detectors

Lensing by Primordial Black Holes: Constraints from Gravitational Wave Observations

GW190521 Mass Gap Event and the Primordial Black Hole Scenario

Constraining high-redshift stellar-mass primordial black holes with next-generation ground-based gravitational-wave detectors

Primordial Black Holes and Secondary Gravitational Waves from String Inspired General No-Scale Supergravity

Gaussian mixture models of the total mass distribution of stellar black holes from LIGO-Virgo GWTC-2: Implications on the origin of GW190521

Constraining the merger history of primordial-black-hole binaries from GWTC-3

Gravitational wave constraints on planetary-mass primordial black holes using LIGO O3a data

Gravitational waves from primordial black hole isocurvature: the effect of non-Gaussianities

Primordial Black Holes from Affleck-Dine Mechanism

Bayesian analysis of LIGO-Virgo mergers: Primordial vs. astrophysical black hole populations