Abstract:Characteristics of the indoor environmental quality directly impact humans’ ability to lead healthy and productive lives. We estimated the effects of changes in indoor air quality (namely through indoor ventilation rates and carbon dioxide levels) on health, performance, and productivity outcomes in students (primary, secondary, and university), laboratory test subjects, and workers. For this systematic review, we searched PubMed, from database inception to October 15, 2020, for relevant studies in any classroom, lab, and labor environment at any level of indoor air quality. No restrictions on language, workers’ health status, or study design were applied. Good and bad indoor air quality was defined using American Society of Heating, Refrigeration, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) standards. We excluded studies that calculated effects focusing on air temperature, humidity levels, systematic reviews on similar topics to avoid duplication, and any grey literature. Of 101 reports identified through our systematic search, 42 studies conducted in 10 countries and 3 continents, including 6,850 subjects were eligible for analysis. Our review showed that individuals exposed to indoor air quality settings above ASHRAE minimum standards (defined as ventilation rates 17 CFM per person and Carbon Dioxide (CO2) steady states of 1000 parts per million (ppm)) were more likely to experience increased poor levels of health, performance and productivity under these conditions. Overall, this analysis includes a variety of populations, exposures, and occupations to comply with a wider adoption of evidence synthesis but resulted in large heterogeneity. Poor indoor air quality has important human health, performance, and productivity outcomes and should be recognized as a public health problem. Inversely, improved indoor environmental conditions delivered through enhanced ventilation strategies should be considered a health, performance, and productivity opportunity for both students and workers. This study addresses these areas of concern and opportunity. However, given the lack of standardized methodologies, results reporting criteria across conducted air quality analyses, and a lack of international case studies, a concerted global effort is needed to conduct and compare research with standardized metrics. Furthermore, a majority of studies are conducted in school classrooms or laboratory environments or provide no remuneration to incentivize good performance - a condition not reflective of real-world office settings. To better understand the implication on office workers, additional field research can serve to enhance our understanding of indoor environmental factors on employee health and productivity in a setting where remuneration incentives may impact performance.

In Pursuit of Healthier Learning Environments: High‐Altitude Classroom Ventilation

Indoor Air Quality and Bioaerosols in Spanish University Classrooms

Indoor air quality analysis in naturally ventilated university training laboratories: a health risk assessment

Air quality monitoring device to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 in educational buildings

Indoor Air Quality in Brazilian Universities

RISK OF BIOAEROSOLS IN SMALL AND POORLY VENTILATED INDOOR PLACES WITH LOW CONCURRENT USE

Indoor air quality in classrooms: Environmental measures and effective ventilation rate modeling in urban elementary schools

Overlooked Impacts of Urban Environments on the Air Quality in Naturally Ventilated Schools Amid the COVID-19 Pandemic

Evaluation of Different Natural Ventilation Strategies by Monitoring the Indoor Air Quality Using CO2 Sensors

Indoor air quality at school and students’ performance: Recommendations of the UNESCO Chair on Health Education and Sustainable Development & the Italian Society of Environmental Medicine (SIMA)

Monitoring and Assessment of Indoor Environmental Conditions in Educational Building Using Building Information Modelling Methodology

Influence of Surrounding Environment and Occupancy

Understanding teachers' experiences of ventilation in California K‐12 classrooms and implications for supporting safe operation of schools in the wake of the COVID‐19 pandemic

Analysis of Impact of Natural Ventilation Strategies in Ventilation Rates and Indoor Environmental Acoustics Using Sensor Measurement Data in Educational Buildings

Towards a Living Lab for Enhanced Thermal Comfort and Air Quality: Analyses of Standard Occupancy, Weather Extremes, and COVID-19 Pandemic

Influence of indoor airflow on airborne disease transmission in a classroom

A comprehensive assessment of IAQ role in ensuring environment quality and health in schools and plan for future school environment: a systematic review

Comprehensive analysis of classroom microclimate in context to health-related national and international indoor air quality standards

Numerical study of different ventilation schemes in a classroom for efficient aerosol control

Human Health and Productivity Outcomes Associated with Indoor Air Quality: a Systematic Review

How teacher behaviors and perceptions, air change rates, and portable air purifiers affect indoor air quality in naturally ventilated schools