From the Hofstadter to the Fibonacci butterfly

Gerardo G. Naumis,F.J. Lopez-Rodriguez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physb.2007.10.016

2006-10-07

Abstract:We show that the electronic spectrum of a tight-binding Hamiltonian defined in a quasiperiodic chain with an on-site potential given by a Fibonacci sequence, can be obtained as a superposition of Harper potentials. The electronic spectrum of the Harper equation is a fractal set, known as Hofstadter butterfly. Here we show that is possible to construct a similar butterfly for the Fibonacci potential just by adding harmonics to the Harper potential. As a result, the equations in reciprocal space for the Fibonacci case have the form of a chain with a long range interaction between Fourier components. Then we explore the transformation between both spectra, and specifically the origin of energy gaps due to the analytical calculation of the components in reciprocal space of the potentials. We also calculate some localization properties by finding the correlator of each potential.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand and construct an electronic spectrum similar to the Hofstadter butterfly, but for the Fibonacci quasi - periodic chain. Specifically, the author hopes to obtain the Fibonacci potential by superimposing the Harper potential and study its properties and transitions in the reciprocal space.

### Main problems and goals:
1. **Constructing the Fibonacci potential**: The author shows how to construct the Fibonacci potential by superimposing multiple Harper potentials.
2. **Exploring spectral changes**: Study the spectral change process from the Harper model to the Fibonacci model, especially the origin of the energy band gap.
3. **Analyzing localization characteristics**: By calculating the correlation function of each potential, explore the influence of different harmonics on the localization of electron states.
4. **Understanding the electronic properties of quasi - periodic systems**: Through the study of the Fibonacci chain, better understand the propagation characteristics of electrons in quasi - periodic systems, especially the behavior in two - dimensional and three - dimensional cases.

### Specific questions:
- **Why does the Fibonacci model not show a pure - point or continuous spectrum?**
- **Can a spectrum diagram similar to the Hofstadter butterfly be constructed for the Fibonacci chain?**
- **When does the spectrum type change during the process of increasing harmonics?**
- **When does the wave function of the Fibonacci model become a critical state?**

### Methods:
- Use the tight - binding Hamiltonian to describe the system and introduce the Fibonacci sequence as the on - site potential of atoms.
- Expand the Fibonacci potential by Fourier series and represent it as a superposition of Harper potentials.
- Study the interactions in the reciprocal space and the changes in the energy spectrum.
- Calculate the correlation function of the potential to analyze the localization characteristics.

### Conclusions:
The author successfully shows that the Fibonacci potential can be formed by superposing multiple Harper potentials, and as the number of harmonics increases, the spectral structure gradually approaches the Fibonacci butterfly. In addition, they also explore the influence of different harmonics on the spectrum type and localization characteristics, providing a new perspective for further understanding the electronic properties of quasi - periodic systems.

### Key formulas:
- The expression of the Fibonacci potential:
\[
V(n) = 2\delta V\sum_{s = 1}^{\infty}\tilde{V}(s)\cos(2\pi s\phi n)
\]
where \(\tilde{V}(s)=\frac{\sin(\pi s\phi)}{\pi s}\).

- The interaction equation in the reciprocal space:
\[
(E^{*}- 2\delta V^{*}\cos(2\pi\phi m + k))d_{m}=d_{m + 1}+d_{m - 1}+\sum_{s = 2}^{S}\tilde{V}^{*}(s)(d_{m - s}+d_{m + s})
\]

Through these methods and formulas, the author reveals the connection between the Fibonacci model and the Harper model and provides a theoretical basis for future research.