Abstract:Magnets with frustration often show accidental degeneracies, characterized by a large classical ground-state space (CGSS). Quantum fluctuations may "select" one of these ground states—a phenomenon labeled "order by (quantum) disorder" in literature. In this article, we examine the mechanism(s) by which such state selection takes place. We argue that a magnet, at low energies, maps to a particle moving on the CGSS. State selection corresponds to localization of the particle at a certain point on this space. We distinguish two mechanisms that can bring about localization. In the first, quantum fluctuations generate a potential on the CGSS space. If the potential has a deep enough minimum, then the particle localizes in its vicinity. We denote this as "order by potential" (ObP). In the second scenario, the particle localizes at a self-intersection point due to bound-state formation—a consequence of geometry and quantum interference. Following recent studies by the present authors, we denote this scenario as "order by singularity" (ObS). In either case, localization leads to an energy gap between the ground state(s) and higher-energy states. This pseudo-Goldstone gap behaves differently in the two mechanisms, scaling differently with the spin length. We place our discussion within the context of the one-dimensional spin- S Kitaev model. We map out its CGSS which grows systematically with increasing system size. It resembles a network where the number of nodes increases exponentially. In addition, the number of wires that cross at each node also grows exponentially. This self-intersecting structure leads to ObS, with the low-energy physics determined by a small subset of the CGSS, consisting of "Cartesian" states. A contrasting picture emerges when an additional XY antiferromagnetic coupling is introduced. The CGSS simplifies dramatically, taking the form of a circle. Spin wave fluctuations generate a potential on this space, giving rise to state selection by ObP under certain conditions. Apart from contrasting ObS and ObP, we discuss the possibility of ObS in macroscopic magnets. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.103.174412 ©2021 American Physical Society

Comment on "Spurious fixed points in frustrated magnets," <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="cond-mat/0609285" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0609285">cond-mat/0609285</a>

The critical behavior of frustrated spin models with noncollinear order

Frustrated Bonds and Long Range Order in Quasi-2D Magnets

Frustration and Chiral Orderings in Correlated Electron Systems

Lieb-Schultz-Mattis Theorem for 1D Quantum Magnets with Antiunitary Translation and Inversion Symmetries

Frustrated two dimensional quantum magnets

State selection in frustrated magnets

Comment on "Tuning the Magnetic Dimensionality by Charge Ordering in the Molecular TMTTF Salts"

Global fixed point potential approach to frustrated antiferromagnets

Spin and Chirality Orderings of Frustrated Magnets -- Stacked-Triangular Antiferromagnets and Spin Glasses

Field-Induced Non-BEC Transitions in Frustrated Magnets

Frustrated Magnetism of Dipolar Molecules on a Square Optical Lattice: Prediction of a Quantum Paramagnetic Ground State

Quasicrystalline chiral soliton lattices in a Fibonacci helimagnet

Weakening of antiferromagnetism due to frustration on inhomogeneous 2D lattices

Field induced non-BEC transitions in frustrated magnets

Magnetic and quantum disordered phases in triangular-lattice Heisenberg antiferromagnets

Frustration, solitons, and entanglement in spin chains

Strain tuning of highly frustrated magnets: Order and disorder in the distorted kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet

Comment on "Hysteretic transition between states of a filled hexagonal magnetic dipole cluster"

Classical and quantum chiral order in frustrated XY magnets