Packing grains by thermally cycling

K. Chen,J. Cole,C. Conger,J. Draskovic,M. Lohr,K. Klein,T. Scheidemantel,P. Schiffer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/442257a

2006-08-05

Abstract:One of the oldest and most intriguing problems in the handling of materials is how a collection of solid grains packs together. While granular packing is normally determined by how grains are poured or shaken, we find that a systematic and controllable increase in packing is induced by simply raising and lowering the temperature, e.g., without the input of mechanical energy. The results demonstrate that thermal processing provides a largely unexplored mechanism of grain dynamics, as well as an important practical consideration in the handling and storage of granular materials.

Soft Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to systematically and controllably increase the packing density of granular materials through thermal cycling**.

### Specific problem background:
1. **History and importance of granular packing problems**:
- Granular packing is an old and fascinating problem, involving how solid particles are arranged in a container.
- Normally, granular packing is determined by the way of pouring or shaking the particles. However, this paper finds that by simply increasing and decreasing the temperature, a systematic and controllable increase in packing density can be achieved without inputting mechanical energy.

2. **Limitations of traditional methods**:
- Traditional methods for increasing the packing density of granular materials include vibration or tapping, which make the particles pack more closely by inducing small rearrangements.
- Although these methods are effective, they require mechanical energy input and may not be suitable for some application scenarios.

3. **Effects of temperature changes**:
- When the granular material is heated, both the particles and the container will thermally expand. This expansion will lead to the rearrangement of the particles, especially when the particles and the container are made of different materials.
- Previous studies have shown that temperature changes will affect the stress state of silos and granular piles in an industrial environment, but the specific effects of temperature cycling on granular dynamics have not been systematically explored yet.

### Core problems of the paper:
- **How to use temperature cycling to change the packing density of granular materials**, and explore the physical mechanism behind this process.
- **Verify whether temperature cycling can be used as a new method without mechanical energy input** to increase the packing density of granular materials.
- **Study the effects of temperature cycling on the packing density under different material combinations (such as glass balls in plastic containers, plastic balls in glass containers, etc.)** to determine whether the difference in thermal expansion is the main factor.

### Experimental results:
- The experimental results show that even a single temperature cycle can significantly increase the packing density, and the packing density continues to increase after multiple cycles.
- Data fitting shows that the change in packing density can be described by a double - exponential relaxation model, which is related to the large - scale and small - scale rearrangements of the particles.
- Temperature cycling provides an almost adiabatic alternative to mechanical agitation, providing a new mechanism for studying granular packing.

In conclusion, this paper aims to explore temperature cycling as a new, non - mechanical - energy - input method for systematically and controllably increasing the packing density of granular materials and revealing the physical mechanism behind it.