Abstract:In this comment we discuss the problem of reconciling the linear efficiency of price returns with the long-memory of supply and demand. We present new evidence that shows that efficiency is maintained by a liquidity imbalance that co-moves with the imbalance of buyer vs. seller initiated transactions. For example, during a period where there is an excess of buyer initiated transactions, there is also more liquidity for buy orders than sell orders, so that buy orders generate smaller and less frequent price responses than sell orders. At the moment a buy order is placed the transaction sign imbalance tends to dominate, generating a price impact. However, the liquidity imbalance rapidly increases with time, so that after a small number of time steps it cancels all the inefficiency caused by the transaction sign imbalance, bounding the price impact. While the view presented by Bouchaud et al. of a fixed and temporary bare price impact is self-consistent and formally correct, we argue that viewing this in terms of a variable but permanent price impact provides a simpler and more natural view. This is in the spirit of the original conjecture of Lillo and Farmer, but generalized to allow for finite time lags in the build up of the liquidity imbalance after a transaction. We discuss the possible strategic motivations that give rise to the liquidity imbalance and offer an alternative hypothesis. We also present some results that call into question the statistical significance of large swings in expected price impact at long times.

Market reaction to temporary liquidity crises and the permanent market impact

Market efficiency and the long-memory of supply and demand: Is price impact variable and permanent or fixed and temporary?

Structural distortions in the Euro interbank market: The role of 'key players' during the recent market turmoil

Relation between Bid-Ask Spread, Impact and Volatility in Double Auction Markets

Intraday Liquidity and Money Market Dislocations∗

Liquidity Dynamics in an Electronic Open Limit Order Book: an Event Study Approach

Response of double-auction markets to instantaneous Selling-Buying signals with stochastic Bid-Ask spread

Anomalous Price Impact and the Critical Nature of Liquidity in Financial Markets

Deciphering the Libor and Euribor Spreads During the Subprime Crisis

How does latent liquidity get revealed in the limit order book?

Counterparty choice, maturity shifts and market freezes: Lessons from the European interbank market

Endogenous Liquidity Crises

Interbank Transactions on the Intraday Frequency: “Different Market States and the Effects of the Financial Crisis

The adaptive nature of liquidity taking in limit order books

Beyond the Bid-Ask: Strategic Insights into Spread Prediction and the Global Mid-Price Phenomenon

Limit-order book resiliency after effective market orders: spread, depth and intensity

Measuring price impact and information content of trades in a time-varying setting

Liquidity and Impact in Fair Markets

Equity auction dynamics: latent liquidity models with activity acceleration

Liquidity effects of trading frequency

Real-Time Detection of Volatility in Liquidity Provision