Exploring conformational energy landscape of glassy disaccharides by CPMAS 13C NMR and DFT/GIAO simulations. I. Methodological aspects

Ronan Lefort,Patrice Bordat,Attilio Cesaro,Marc Descamps
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2409935
2006-06-15
Abstract:The aim of this article is to assess the ability of chemical shift surfaces to provide structural information on conformational distributions of disaccharides in glassy solid state. The validity of the general method leading to a simulation of inhomogeneous 13C chemical shift distributions is discussed in detail. In particular, a proper consideration of extrema and saddle points of the chemical shift map correctly accounts for the observed discontinuities in the experimental CPMAS spectra. Provided that these basic requirements are met, DFT/GIAO chemical shift maps calculated on relaxed conformations lead to a very satisfactory description of the experimental lineshapes. On solid-state trehalose as a model of amorphous disaccharide, this simulation approach defines unambiguously the most populated sugar conformation in the glass, and can help in discriminating the validity of different models of intramolecular energy landscape. Application to other molecular systems with broad conformational populations is foreseen to produce a larger dependence of the calculated chemical shift distribution on the conformational map.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate whether chemical shift surfaces can provide structural information about the conformational distribution of glassy disaccharides. Specifically, the authors aim to explore the conformational energy landscape of glassy disaccharides through 13C solid - state nuclear magnetic resonance (CPMAS 13C NMR) and density functional theory / Gaussian local orbital (DFT/GIAO) simulations, and verify the effectiveness of these methods in simulating the inhomogeneous 13C chemical shift distribution. ### Summary of Main Problems: 1. **Evaluating the Effectiveness of Chemical Shift Surfaces**: - Researchers hope to obtain structural information about the conformational distribution of glassy disaccharides through chemical shift surfaces. - They explore how to correctly consider the extreme values and saddle points in the chemical shift map to explain the discontinuities in the experimental CPMAS spectra. 2. **Verifying the Accuracy of Simulation Methods**: - By using the chemical shift maps calculated by DFT/GIAO and simulating the relaxed conformations, researchers hope to obtain results that match the experimental line shapes very well. - Taking trehalose as an example, study its most common sugar conformation in the glassy state and help distinguish the effectiveness of different intramolecular energy landscape models. 3. **Application to Other Molecular Systems**: - Researchers also plan to apply this method to other molecular systems with a wide conformational distribution to further verify its applicability and reliability. ### Formula Presentation: - The chemical shift surface $\sigma(\Omega)$ and the energy surface $E(\Omega)$ are calculated in the phase space of the conformational degrees of freedom $\Omega$. - The simulated CPMAS spectrum $S(\delta)$ can be calculated by the following formula: \[ S(\delta) = \int_{\nabla \sigma(\phi, \psi)=\delta} \rho(\sigma) \chi(\phi, \psi) \, d\phi \, d\psi \] where $\sigma(\phi, \psi)$ is the chemical shift of the carbon atom, $\chi(\phi, \psi)$ is the conformational occupation probability density, and $\rho(\sigma)$ is the angular density state. ### Methodological Aspects: - **Experimental Part**: Prepare amorphous (glassy) trehalose samples by ball - milling method and conduct 13C CPMAS experiments using a Bruker AV400 solid - state NMR spectrometer. - **Molecular Modeling**: Use Hyperchem Pro 7 software to generate and optimize all conformations, especially generate different conformations by constraining two dihedral angles $\phi$ and $\psi$. - **Energy and Chemical Shift Maps**: Obtain the lowest energy conformation (LMC) through molecular mechanics optimization, and calculate the energy map $E(\phi, \psi)$ and the chemical shift map $\sigma(C_x, \phi, \psi)$ at each $(\phi, \psi)$ point. - **Simulating CPMAS Spectra**: Through numerical integration and interpolation methods, combined with experimental data, evaluate the degree of agreement between different force fields and models with the experimental results. In conclusion, this paper aims to provide an effective method to understand the conformational distribution of glassy disaccharides and their related energy landscapes by combining experiments and simulations, thus providing valuable references for future related research.