Abstract:In this letter we explore the Higgs instability in the gapless superfluid/superconducting phase. This is in addition to the (chromo)magnetic instability that is related to the fluctuations of the Nambu-Goldstone bosonic fields. While the latter may induce a single-plane-wave LOFF state, the Higgs instability favors spatial inhomogeneity and cannot be removed without a long range force. In the case of the g2SC state the Higgs instability can only be partially removed by the electric Coulomb energy. But this does not exclude the possibility that it can be completely removed in other exotic states such as the gCFL state.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Astrophysics,Superconductivity,Nuclear Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the influence of Higgs instability in the gapless superfluidity/superconductivity phase. Specifically, the author studies how this instability affects the system and explores its relationship with chromomagnetic instability.
### Main problems
1. **Higgs instability**: What is the breakdown mechanism of BCS superconductors when the Fermi momenta do not match? In particular, in the gapless superconducting phase, how does Higgs instability affect the stability of the system and possible phase transitions?
2. **Phase separation and LOFF state**: In some experiments, why is the phase separation phenomenon observed instead of the BP state or LOFF state? Does Higgs instability contribute to this?
3. **Influence of Coulomb interaction**: Can the long - range Coulomb interaction caused by charge fluctuations completely eliminate Higgs instability?
### Specific content
- **Background introduction**:
- The paper discusses superfluid/superconducting systems with mismatched Fermi momenta, such as neutral dense quark matter, asymmetric nuclear matter, and unbalanced cold - atom gases.
- It mentions the Larkin - Ovchinnikov - Fulde - Ferrel (LOFF) state, which is an unconventional superconducting phase induced by the competition between pairing breaking and pairing condensation.
- The concepts of the gapless superconducting phase and the broken - pairing (BP) phase are introduced, and these phases form when the mismatch of Fermi momenta is large.
- **Higgs instability**:
- Higgs instability is related to the fluctuations of the superconducting order - parameter amplitude, resulting in spatial inhomogeneity.
- By analyzing the changes in thermodynamic potential and free energy, the influence of Higgs instability on the stability of the system is studied.
- In the weak - coupling limit, the Higgs self - energy function \(\Pi(k)\) is derived, and it is found to be negative for certain wave vectors \(k\), indicating the existence of instability.
- **Coulomb interaction**:
- The influence of the long - range Coulomb interaction caused by charge fluctuations on Higgs instability is studied.
- It is found that although the Coulomb interaction can partially eliminate Higgs instability in the low - wave - vector and high - wave - vector regions, instability still exists in the intermediate - wave - vector region.
- **Conclusion**:
- Higgs instability may lead to phase separation rather than the formation of the BP state or LOFF state.
- For neutral two - flavor quark matter, the Coulomb interaction can partially eliminate Higgs instability, but it still exists in certain wave - vector ranges.
- It is proposed that there may be a ground state with a crystal structure, such as a heterogeneous mixture of normal and superconducting phases or a multi - plane - wave LOFF state.
### Mathematical formulas
- Thermodynamic potential density:
\[
\Omega = -\lim_{V \to \infty} \frac{T}{V} \ln \text{Tr} e^{-\beta H+\nu N}
\]
- Free - energy density:
\[
F=\Omega+\nu n
\]
- Higgs self - energy function:
\[
\Pi(k)=\frac{1}{4G_D}-T \sum_n \int \frac{d^3 p}{(2\pi)^3} \text{tr}[S_M(P) \gamma_5 \epsilon_3 \tau_2 \rho_2 S_M(P - K) \gamma_5 \epsilon_3 \tau_2 \rho_2]
\]
- Coulomb energy density:
\[
E_{\text{coul}}=\frac{1}{2V} \sum_{\vec{k} \neq 0} \frac{\delta \rho(\vec{k})^* \delta \rho(\vec{k})}{k^2 + m_D^2(k)}
\]
Through these studies, the paper reveals the important role of Higgs instability in the gapless superfluidity/superconductivity phase and paves the way for further research.