The Evolution of Low Mass Helium Stars towards Supernova Type I Explosion

Roni Waldman,Zalman Barkat
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0605692
2006-11-21
Abstract:We explore the hypothesis, that helium stars in a certain mass range can evolve to a carbon core explosion similar to what is widely accepted as an explanation for the SN I phenomenon. This should happen when their carbon-oxygen core grows thanks to the helium shell burning above the core. We found that in the mass range of about 1.7-2.2 Msun, indeed this can happen. The main new insight we believe we gained is the crucial importance of an "early" off-center ignition of carbon, which at a later stage prevents the carbon which forms below the helium burning shell and ignites, from burning the carbon all the way to the center. When helium is almost depleted in the convective envelope by the helium burning shell at its bottom, the now super-Chandrasekhar mass carbon-oxygen core contracts, and the residual degenerate carbon at the center is ignited, resulting in a runaway similar to the classical SN I scenario. Since the structure and behavior of the carbon-oxygen core of the helium stars of our interest is very similar to that of a mass accreting carbon-oxygen star, we also thoroughly examined the behavior of carbon-oxygen stars. We discovered that the models which ignite carbon off-center (in the mass range of about 1.05-1.18 Msun, depending on the carbon mass fraction) present an interesting SN I progenitor scenario of their own, since whereas in the standard scenario runaway always takes place at the same density of about 2E9 gr/cm3, in our case, due to the small amount of carbon ignited, we get a whole range of densities from 1E9 up to 6E9 gr/cm3.
Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Can low - mass helium stars within a specific mass range evolve into carbon - core explosions similar to Type Ia supernovae (SN Ia)?** Specifically, the author explores whether the internal physical processes of helium stars with masses between 1.4 and 2.5 solar masses will eventually cause them to undergo a violent carbon - burning explosion, thereby explaining the phenomenon of Type Ia supernovae. ### Main problem decomposition: 1. **Selection of mass range**: - The paper focuses on helium stars with masses between 1.7 and 2.2 solar masses. This mass range is selected because within this range, the core mass of the helium star can grow close to the Chandrasekhar limit (about 1.4 solar masses) and carbon burning is likely to occur. 2. **Trigger mechanism of carbon burning**: - The author finds that within this mass range, the burning of the helium shell will gradually increase the core mass, and when the temperature is high enough, the newly produced carbon will ignite at a position far from the center, forming an outward - propagating carbon - burning shell. - The key new insight is "early off - center ignition of carbon". This ignition occurs during the outward propagation of the helium - burning shell, causing the carbon - burning shell to move inward, but eventually stops due to the previously formed carbon - depleted region. 3. **Differences from the standard Type Ia supernova model**: - In the standard Type Ia supernova model, a white dwarf gradually grows close to the Chandrasekhar limit by accreting matter and then ignites carbon at the center, triggering an explosion. - In the helium star model, the helium star already has a non - negligible envelope in its later evolutionary stage, containing helium and carbon - burning products, and may even have some oxygen - burning products. Moreover, carbon burning in the helium star can occur at different densities, rather than always at the same density as in the standard model. ### Main contributions of the paper: - Proposes the possibility of helium stars as progenitors of Type Ia supernovae, especially in the mass range of 1.7 to 2.2 solar masses. - Emphasizes the importance of early off - center carbon ignition, which may lead to different explosion results and explains the observed diversity of Type Ia supernovae. - Provides detailed numerical simulations and theoretical analyses, providing a basis for further research. ### Future research directions: - Further research on the influence of mass loss on the evolution of helium stars is required, especially how it affects the mass distribution of helium stars. - More accurate simulation of the stability of thermal convection and double - shell burning (helium and carbon - burning shells) is needed. - The explosion process needs to be simulated in detail and the results compared with observational data to verify the validity of the model. In summary, this paper aims to explore whether helium stars within a specific mass range can become Type Ia supernovae through carbon - burning explosions and proposes new physical mechanisms to explain this phenomenon.