When hot water freezes before cold

J. I. Katz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/1.2996187

2006-04-28

Abstract:I suggest that the origin of the Mpemba effect (the freezing of hot water before cold) is freezing-point depression by solutes, either gaseous or solid, whose solubility decreases with increasing temperature so that they are removed when water is heated. They are concentrated ahead of the freezing front by zone refining in water that has not been heated, reduce the temperature of the freezing front, and thereby reduce the temperature gradient and heat flux, slowing the progress of the front. I present a simple calculation of this effect, and suggest experiments to test this hypothesis.

Chemical Physics,Statistical Mechanics,General Physics,Popular Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explain the Mpemba effect, that is, the phenomenon that hot water freezes faster than cold water. This phenomenon is counter - intuitive because under normal circumstances, people would think that hot water needs to be cooled to the temperature of cold water first and then freeze according to the cooling path of cold water. However, this phenomenon has been recorded in multiple cultures and can be traced back to the time of Aristotle at the earliest.

### Main problems and hypotheses

The main contribution of the paper is to propose a possible mechanism to explain the Mpemba effect. The author J. I. Katz proposes that the reason why hot water freezes faster than cold water may be that the solubility of solutes (such as gases or minerals) decreases with increasing temperature. Specifically:

1. **Solute solubility change**: When water is heated, the solubility of certain solutes (for example, gases or minerals) will decrease, causing these solutes to precipitate out of the water.
2. **Zone - refining effect**: In unheated water, these solutes will be concentrated at the freezing front, thereby reducing the temperature of the freezing front and slowing down the freezing process.
3. **Freezing - point depression**: The presence of solutes will cause the freezing point of water to decrease. Since the heated water has lost some solutes, its freezing point is relatively higher, so it is easier to freeze.

### Mathematical model

To quantify this effect, the author carried out simple calculations and proposed the following formula to describe the degree of freezing - point depression:

\[
\Delta T_m=R T_m^2 / H_m
\]

where:
- \( \Delta T_m \) is the temperature of freezing - point depression,
- \( R \) is the gas constant,
- \( T_m \) is the freezing - point temperature of pure water,
- \( H_m \) is the enthalpy of fusion.

For an ideal dilute solution, the magnitude of freezing - point depression is:

\[
\Delta T_m = 1.86^{\circ}\text{C}/\text{molal}
\]

In addition, the author also discussed how the solute concentration changes during the freezing process. By solving the diffusion equation, the change of solute concentration with time and space was obtained:

\[
\frac{\partial C(x, t)}{\partial t}+v(t) \frac{\partial C(x, t)}{\partial x}-D \frac{\partial^2 C(x, t)}{\partial x^2}=0
\]

where:
- \( C(x, t) \) is the solute concentration,
- \( v(t) \) is the velocity of liquid flowing to the freezing front,
- \( D \) is the diffusion coefficient of the solute in the liquid phase.

### Experimental suggestions

The author also suggests conducting experiments to verify this hypothesis. In particular, the change in freezing time can be observed by measuring water samples with different solute concentrations at different initial temperatures. This helps to further understand the physical mechanism behind the Mpemba effect.

In conclusion, this paper provides a new perspective to explain the Mpemba effect by introducing solute solubility change and zone - refining effect, and proposes corresponding mathematical models and experimental suggestions.