A puzzling Mule Coin from the Parabita Hoard: a Material Characterisation

G. Giovannelli,S. Natali,B. Bozzini,D. Manno,G. Micocci,A. Serra,G. Sarcinelli,A. Siciliano,R. Vitale

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0603438

2006-03-16

Abstract:In this research, we report on the compositional, microstructural and crystallographic properties of a lead coin which has been regarded for many years as a genuine silver coin minted in the Southern Italy in the course of the 4th century BC. The material characterisation of this object allowed detecting an ancient forging technology, not previously reported, which was meant for the silvering of lead substrates The data collected have disclosed a contemporary counterfeiting procedure based on a metal coating process onto a Pb substrate. This coating has been identified as a bi-layer with a Cu innermost and an Ag outermost visible layer. As far as the coating application technique is concerned, the gathered evidence has clearly indicated that the original appearance of this artifact cannot be explained in terms of any of the established methods for the growth of an artificially silvered coating in classical antiquity. This technology is now being explained in terms of modern, fully non destructive scientific methods.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the real composition and manufacturing process of a silver coin, which was believed to be minted in southern Italy in the 4th century BC. Through material characterization, the researchers found that the coin was actually made of lead and had a double - layer coating of copper and silver on its surface. This discovery reveals an ancient counterfeiting technique that has not been reported before, which was used to make the lead substrate appear silver.

### Specific problems and solutions

1. **The real composition of the coin**:
- The coin has long been considered a genuine silver coin, but through material characterization (such as EDX, SEM, XRD, etc.), the researchers found that the main component of the coin is lead, not silver.
- The core of the coin is an alloy composed of 90 - 95% lead and a small amount of antimony, and the surface is covered with a double - layer coating of copper and silver.

2. **Identification of ancient counterfeiting techniques**:
- Through microstructure and crystallography analysis, the researchers discovered that this coin used an ancient forging technique that has not been reported before. This technique includes coating a layer of copper on the lead substrate and then coating a layer of silver.
- The formation method of this double - layer coating is different from the known ancient counterfeiting methods (such as the heat treatment method of Assyrian silver coins or various surface treatment methods), indicating that this is a new and unique ancient counterfeiting technique.

3. **The possibility of electrochemical deposition**:
- Through SEM images and XRD data, the researchers found that the morphology and crystal orientation of the coating (especially the preferred orientation of the (111) plane) are more in line with the electrochemical deposition process rather than the traditional heat treatment or machining methods.
- This finding further supports the view that this ancient counterfeiting technique may be achieved by electrochemical methods.

### Conclusion

This study reveals an unknown ancient counterfeiting technique in the past. This technique creates counterfeit coins that look like silver coins by coating a double - layer of copper and silver on the lead substrate. This technique is different from the known heat treatment methods and other surface treatment techniques, indicating that ancient craftsmen may have mastered relatively complex metal coating techniques. This discovery not only provides a new perspective for understanding ancient currency counterfeiting but also provides valuable data for the study of archaeological metallurgy.

### Related formulas and terms

- **EDX (Energy - dispersive X - ray spectroscopy)**: Energy - dispersive X - ray spectroscopy, used to determine the elemental composition of a sample.
- **SEM (Scanning Electron Microscopy)**: Scanning electron microscopy, used to observe the microscopic morphology of a sample.
- **XRD (X - ray Diffraction)**: X - ray diffraction, used to analyze the crystal structure of a sample.
- **Cu Kα radiation**: Copper target Kα radiation, often used as an excitation source in XRD experiments.
- **(111) preferred orientation**: (111) - plane preferred orientation, which means that the crystals are more orderly arranged in a specific direction.

The application of these techniques enables researchers to analyze the composition and structure of the coin in detail, thereby revealing its real manufacturing process.