AN ELECTROCHEMICAL APPROACH FOR INVESTIGATING CORROSION OF SMALL ARMS MUNITIONS IN FIRING RANGES
K. Bundy,M. Bricka,A. Morales
Abstract:Corrosion of spent munitions in soil has never been previously investigated. Because of the possible environmental impact of lead leaching from bullets, this project was initiated to investigate the usefulness of electrochemical methods for measuring corrosion rates of bullets in soil. The electrolyte was soil taken from a Southern army training facility. A number of environmental conditions were simulated (rain water, acid rain, sea water, and a sea water/acid rain mixture) at moisture contents of 15% and saturation. The validity of using electrochemical techniques for measuring bullet corrosion has been established in this research. Corrosion current was observed to be very dependent on environmental conditions. The rate of corrosion was found to increase with decreasing pH and increasing chloride and moisture contents. High soil resistance and a relatively less negative value for corrosion potential were found to be associated with low corrosion rates. This is an important result since both soil resistivity and potential can be readily measured under field conditions. Additional laboratory and field studies are needed to obtain further insight into the bullet corrosion problem, including additional electrochemical tests, weight loss measurements, chemical analyses of soils, and other soil measurements. K EYWORDS: bullets, corrosion, lead, soil, electrochemical techniques To whom all correspondence should be addressed (Biomedical Engineering Department, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, 70118, Phone: 504-865-5897, FAX: 504-862-8779). INTRODUCTION Over the years there have been many reports on the corrosion behavior of metals in soil. For the most part, however, these studies have been concerned with underground structures made from ferrous alloys, e.g., water mains [1], pilings [2], gas pipelines [3], and underground storage tanks [4]. Much less is known about electrochemical dissolution of nonferrous metals in soils. It appears that one corrosion problem of possibly significant environmental importance that has been overlooked in the past is that of spent small arms munitions in soil environments. For several decades at military firing ranges, used bullets have been accumulating in soils. A wide spectrum of soil types and weathering conditions is involved. Typically military bullets consist of a lead alloy slug surrounded by a copper alloy jacket. Lead is a well-known neurotoxin [5] and causes other health problems as well [6]. Although not harmful to the degree that lead is, copper is also considered to be a toxic metal. Therefore, the release of soluble and precipitated corrosion products into soil is of potential concern, particularly regarding the possibility of their infiltration into ground water. The literature regarding underground corrosion of lead alloys is much sparser than that pertaining to iron and steel. Studies of lead sheathing of concentric neutral underground telecommunication cables have been reported [7-9]. The extensive NBS soil corrosion research projects [10] utilized lead alloys for a very small percentage of the exposed specimens. Von Baeckmann [11] has reported on the cathodic corrosion of lead in soil. Booth, et al. [12], investigated soil characteristics that foster aggressive corrosion in a variety of nonferrous materials including lead and copper. Solid radioactive wastes are sometimes stored in underground containers made of lead, and some research has been reported regarding their corrosion behavior [13, 14]. A literature search turned up only one reference dealing with corrosion of bullets in soil [15], and none in the English language. The study of Shimodaira, et al. [15], investigated stress corrosion cracking behavior of brass bullets. There are various approaches for the study of corrosion phenomena. In weight loss investigations, the specimen is exposed to the conditions of interest for a defined time period. The specimen is weighed before and after the corrosion has occurred, and the difference represents the weight lost into the environment by corrosion processes. Atoms of metal M, though, are lost from the surface by oxidation reactions such as: M → M + ne, where n is the atomic valence and e is the charge on the electron. In a macroscopic sense this means that a current flows through the metal surface. Consequently, the rate of weight loss into solution (i.e., the corrosion rate) at any given instant can be determined by measuring the current flowing through the metal/electrolyte interface. The term “electrolyte” in this context refers to the medium in which corrosion is occurring. Methods which monitor corrosion processes by determining currents and electrical potentials of the metal of interest are known as electrochemical techniques. Weight loss methods were the first ones used to study corrosion, but in recent decades the electrochemical approach has also become a traditional means for measuring corrosion. Electrochemical methods offer the advantage over weight loss tests in that they can be carried out much more quickly. Thus they lend themselves to studies where many different environments are tested. Usually electrochemical testing has been applied to corrosion in aqueous liquid environments, although these techniques have been extended to a variety of other environments, also, such as soils. Excellent descriptions of these two approaches for studying corrosion are found in the literature [16, 17]. Few of the studies of lead corrosion mentioned above, however, used electrochemical techniques to monitor the rate of corrosion, and only one [15] could be identified which addressed small arms munitions corrosion in soils. The investigation of Shimodaira, et al. [15], though, did not employ electrochemical methods. The purpose of the present investigation is to study the utility and validity of the electrochemical testing approach for gauging the severity of corrosion under a range of soil conditions that might be encountered by spent bullets in the field. Ultimately it is hoped that such studies will allow determination of the soil/weathering conditions that pose the greatest hazard for lead release into soil. This should aid in guiding remediation efforts and/or future activities in the area of soil treatment to minimize corrosion of bullets. A number of variables [1, 2, 4, 9, 12, 18, 19] have been shown to be implicated in the corrosion of metallic structures in soil, e.g., moisture content, pH, resistivity, and redox potential. Fungi have also been reported to be corrosive to lead [20]. Soil chemistry, particularly that of pore water, can also have a substantial influence on the corrosivity of soil. Carbonates, chlorides, sulfates, and sulfides have been identified as being particularly important. The present study focuses on the importance of moisture content, pH, and chloride content on bullet corrosion. The other variables mentioned above will be examined in future investigations. M ATERIALS AND METHODS