Unified Theory of Allometric Scaling

Jafferson K. L. da Silva,Lauro A. Barbosa,Paulo Roberto Silva
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0603063
2007-10-05
Abstract:A general simple theory for the interspecific allometric scaling is developed in the $d+1$-dimensional space ($d$ biological lengths and a physiological time) of metabolic states of organisms. It is assumed that natural selection shaped the metabolic states in such a way that the mass and energy $d+1$-densities are size-invariant quantities (independent of body mass). The different metabolic states (basal and maximum) are described by considering that the biological lengths and the physiological time are related by different transport processes of energy and mass. In the basal metabolism, transportation occurs by ballistic and diffusion processes. In $d=3$, the 3/4 law occurs if the ballistic movement is the dominant process, while the 2/3 law appears when both transport processes are equivalent. Accelerated movement during the biological time is related to the maximum aerobic sustained metabolism, which is characterized by the scaling exponent $2d/(2d+1)$ (6/7 in $d=3$). The results are in good agreement with empirical data and a verifiable empirical prediction about the aorta blood velocity in maximum metabolic rate conditions is made.
Biological Physics,Popular Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the allometric scaling between the metabolic rate (MR) among organisms and body weight. Specifically, the authors explored the following key issues: 1. **Is there a universal basal metabolic rate (BMR) index \( b \) across species?** - For a long time, Kleiber's law has pointed out that there is a relationship of \( B \propto M^{3/4} \) between BMR and body weight \( M \). However, this conclusion has been questioned in recent years. Some studies believe that the index \( b \) may be \( 2/3 \) or vary among different species. 2. **Is there a model that can simultaneously describe the allometric scaling relationships of basal metabolic rate (BMR) and maximum metabolic rate (MMR)?** - BMR and MMR represent the metabolic rates of animals at rest and during high - intensity activities respectively. Previous studies have shown that the allometric scaling index of MMR is usually greater than that of BMR, but there is a lack of a unified theory to explain this difference. 3. **Which physiological variables are determined by BMR and which are determined by MMR?** - Different metabolic states may affect different physiological parameters, such as heart rate, capillary density, etc. Understanding how these variables change with metabolic states is crucial for revealing the adaptation mechanisms of organisms. ### Research Methods To answer the above questions, the authors proposed a general theoretical framework based on the following assumptions: - **Natural selection keeps the mass density \( \rho_{d + 1} \) and energy density \( \sigma_{d+1} \) constant in organisms of different body sizes.** - **Metabolic states can be described by lengths \( L_1, L_2,\cdots, L_d \) in \( d \)-dimensional space and time \( \tau \).** - **Different metabolic processes (such as diffusion, convection, inertial motion) dominate different metabolic states.** Through these assumptions, the authors derived a series of formulas to describe the allometric scaling relationships of organisms in different metabolic states. For example: - For basal metabolic rate (BMR), if convection is dominant, then \( B \propto M^{3/4} \); if diffusion and convection are comparable, then \( B \propto M^{2/3} \). - For maximum metabolic rate (MMR), if inertial motion is dominant, then \( B \propto M^{6/7} \). ### Conclusions This theory can not only explain the existing experimental data, but also propose new verifiable predictions, such as the increase in aortic blood flow velocity with body weight under maximum metabolic rate conditions. This provides an important theoretical basis and experimental direction for future research. In general, by introducing the concepts of length and time in multi - dimensional space and combining natural selection and material transport processes, this paper provides a unified theoretical framework to explain the allometric scaling relationships in different metabolic states, thus resolving the long - standing controversy regarding the allometric scaling relationships of metabolic rates.