The correlations between BL Lacs and ultra-high-energy cosmic rays deflected by using different GMF models

Zhen Cao,Ben Zhong Dai,Jian Ping Yang,Li Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0602480

2006-02-26

Abstract:Some studies suggested that a correlation between locations of BL Lacertae objects (BL Lacs) and the arrival directions of the ultrahigh energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) exists. Especially by assuming the primary particles charged +1 and using a galactic magnetic field (GMF) model to calculate the deflections of the UHECRs, the significance of correlation is improved. We construct a new GMF model by incorporating all progresses in the GMF measurements in recent years. Based on a thorough study of the deflections of the UHECRs measured by the AGASA experiment, we study the GFM model dependence of the correlation between the UHECRs and the selected BL Lacs using the new model together with others. It turns out that only specific one of those GMF models makes the correlation significant, even if neither GMF models themselves nor deflections of the UHECRs are not significantly different. It suggests that the significance of the correlation, calculated using a method suggested in those studies, is intensively depending on the GMF model. Great improvement in statistics may help to suppress the sensitivity to the GMF models.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore and solve the following problems:

1. **Correlation between Ultra - High - Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECRs) and BL Lac objects**:
- Some studies suggest that there may be a correlation between the positions of BL Lac objects and the arrival directions of Ultra - High - Energy Cosmic Rays. In particular, when assuming that the primary particles have a charge of +1 and using the Galactic Magnetic Field (GMF) model to calculate the deflections of UHECRs, the significance of this correlation is enhanced.

2. **The influence of different Galactic Magnetic Field models on the correlation**:
- Researchers have constructed a new GMF model, incorporating all the progress in GMF measurements in recent years. Based on the UHECRs data measured by the AGASA experiment, the influence of different GMF models on the correlation between UHECRs and selected BL Lac objects has been studied.
- The results show that only specific GMF models can make this correlation significant, even if there are no significant differences in the different GMF models themselves or in the deflections of UHECRs. This indicates that the significance of the correlation calculated using certain methods is highly dependent on the selected GMF model.

3. **The importance of statistical improvement**:
- A substantial increase in the amount of statistical data may help to reduce the sensitivity to GMF models, thereby enabling a more accurate assessment of the correlation between UHECRs and BL Lac objects.

### Formula summary

- **Definition of deflection angle**:
\[
\text{Deflection angle}=\theta_{\text{observed}}-\theta_{\text{primary}}
\]
where \(\theta_{\text{observed}}\) is the observed UHECR direction and \(\theta_{\text{primary}}\) is the original direction of UHECR outside the Milky Way.

- **Probability function \(p(\delta)\)**:
\[
p(\delta)=\frac{\text{The number of times } N_{mc}\geq N_{\text{real}}\text{ in the test set}}{\text{Total number of tests}}
\]
where \(N_{\text{real}}\) is the number of actual events matching the source and \(N_{mc}\) is the number of simulated events matching the source.

Through these analyses, the paper hopes to reveal the influence of different GMF models on the correlation between UHECRs and BL Lac objects and provide guidance for future high - energy cosmic ray research.