Location and Price Competition on a Uniform Path with Different Pricing Policies

Joyendu Bhadury,H. A. Eiselt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11067-024-09631-5

2024-06-27

Networks and Spatial Economics

Abstract:This paper models duopolistic competition between an online retailer and a physical store retailer with the online retailer modelled as a firm with uniform delivered pricing policy and the physical store as a firm with a mill pricing policy. Both firms seek to maximize their respective profits through an appropriate choice of location and price. The market is assumed to be given by a "uniform path" - a tree whose node weights and arc lengths are equal. Modelling reality, we consider two alternate types of transportation costs faced by the online retailer: either dependent on the relative location of the firm and a customer or independent of it. Beginning with the framework of a Stackelberg, i.e., sequential game, optimal location and price strategies are analytically derived for both sequences of market entry by the two competitors. Cases in which the leader faces the first entry paradox or can become a monopolist by strategically deterring entry by the follower are delineated. Thereafter, Nash Equilibrium solutions to the simultaneous game are identified. Salient insights from the results include: (a) the competitive pressure faced by the physical store in the presence of online competition (b) the inability of an online retailer to compete in "large" markets under the first type of transportation cost and (c) the advantage to the physical retailer of being a market leader.

transportation science & technology,operations research & management science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to study the location and pricing strategies of online retailers and physical stores in competition. Specifically, the author constructs a duopoly competition model, in which one retailer adopts a uniform delivered pricing policy (representing online retailers), and the other retailer adopts a mill pricing policy (representing physical stores). Both sides maximize their respective profits by choosing the optimal location and price.

#### Main problems:
1. **Competition under different pricing policies**: Online retailers adopt uniform delivered pricing, while physical stores adopt mill pricing. How does this asymmetric pricing policy affect the competition strategies of both sides?
2. **The influence of market entry order**: Research on the optimal strategies under two market entry orders:
- Online retailers as leaders and physical stores as followers.
- Physical stores as leaders and online retailers as followers.
3. **The first - entry paradox**: Explore whether the leader will, in some cases, be unable to obtain positive profits and thus not enter the market.
4. **The possibility of market monopoly**: Analyze whether the leader can prevent the follower from entering through strategic choices and thus become a market monopolist.

#### Model settings:
- **Market structure**: Assume that the market is a "uniform path", that is, all node weights and side lengths in the tree diagram are equal.
- **Transportation costs**: Consider two types of transportation costs faced by online retailers:
- **Location - dependent transportation costs**: Transportation costs are linearly related to the distance between customers and retailers.
- **Location - independent transportation costs**: Transportation costs are fixed for each customer and are independent of distance.
- **Consumer preferences**: When the delivery prices are the same, consumers are more inclined to choose physical stores.

#### Research methods:
- Use the Stackelberg game framework, that is, sequential games, to analyze the optimal strategies of leaders and the reaction functions of followers.
- Derive closed - form solutions under different market entry orders to determine the optimal location and price strategies.

#### Key findings:
- **The competitive pressure faced by physical stores**: The existence of online retailers brings significant competitive pressure to physical stores.
- **The disadvantages of online retailers in large markets**: Under location - dependent transportation costs, it is difficult for online retailers to compete effectively in "large" markets.
- **The competitive advantage of physical stores as leaders**: Physical stores have certain advantages as market leaders.

Through these analyses, the paper provides in - depth insights into the competition strategies of online retailers and physical stores under different market conditions and reveals some phenomena that may occur in reality.