Abstract:The Internet of Things (IoT) is a technological paradigm that has gained significant momentum the last decade and, among other features, enables the development of intelligent and interoperable device networks. In this respect, it has triggered the creation and evolution of vehicular ad-hoc networks (VANETs), which are initially implemented in order to guarantee the safety of drivers and the avoidance of traffic accidents. The drawback is that this fast evolution comes with serious concerns in terms of the privacy of users, while the population of attackers or entities that try to eavesdrop and intercept information has significantly increased. This imposes a serious risk for drivers moving across a Smart City. The research presented in this paper aims to evaluate privacy protection mechanisms in VANET environments, based on the efficiency and security level they ensure, considering the fact that VANETs provide limited resources to users/drivers. Moreover, the usage of elliptic curve cryptography in reduced resources environments is discussed. Finally, this paper compares the performance of three cryptographic algorithms, elliptic curve cryptography (ECC), hyperelliptic curve cryptography genus 2 (HECC-2) and HECC genus 3 (HECC-3), employed for an efficient authentication and safe message transmission mechanism in VANETs, aimed at reaching conclusions related to the implementation of each cryptographic scheme in this specific application area. The evaluation results indicate that ECC supersedes HECC-2 and HECC-3 in most metrics. However, HECC-2 and HECC-3 demonstrate better responses than ECC does in selected energy metrics. Overall, it is observed that HECC algorithms are not yet mature enough to compete with ECC. This is due to the fact that the research community has not sufficiently progressed toward the optimization of HECC, and moreover, HECC builds on quite complex mathematics. There are indications, however, that once HECC curves are indeed optimized, HECC will outperform ECC in speed as well as in other metrics, sinceHECC-2 and HECC-3 use a significantly smaller key size with the same level of security as that of ECC.

An ECC-based access control scheme with lightweight decryption and conditional authentication for data sharing in vehicular networks

A Novel Anonymous Authentication Scheme Based on Edge Computing in Internet of Vehicles

Efficient and Secure Access Control Scheme in the Standard Model for Vehicular Cloud Computing

An Identity-Based and Revocable Data-Sharing Scheme in VANETs

Adaptive Multimedia Data Forwarding for Privacy Preservation in Vehicular Ad-Hoc Networks.

Extensible Conditional Privacy Protection Authentication Scheme for Secure Vehicular Networks in a Multi-Cloud Environment

An Efficient and Provably Secure ECC-Based Conditional Privacy-Preserving Authentication for Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communication in VANETs

Publicly Accountable Data-sharing Scheme Supporting Privacy Protection for Fog-enabled VANETs

SEMD: Secure and Efficient Message Dissemination with Policy Enforcement in VANET

Efficient ECC-based Conditional Privacy-preserving Aggregation Signature Scheme in V2V

An Efficient Elliptic Curve Cryptography‐Based Secure Communication with Privacy Preserving for Autonomous Vehicle

An efficient certificateless anonymous signcryption communication scheme for vehicular adhoc network

Dynamic Privacy-Preserving Anonymous Authentication Scheme for Condition-Matching in Fog-Cloud-Based VANETs

Secure and Lightweight Conditional Privacy-Preserving Authentication for Securing Traffic Emergency Messages in VANETs

Fog-Aided Verifiable Privacy Preserving Access Control for Latency-Sensitive Data Sharing in Vehicular Cloud Computing

SACP: A Signcryption-Based Authentication Scheme with Conditional Privacy Preservation for VANET.

ECCHSC: Computationally and Bandwidth Efficient ECC-Based Hybrid Signcryption Protocol for Secure Heterogeneous Vehicle-to-Infrastructure Communications

Enhancing Privacy in the Internet of Vehicles via Hyperelliptic Curve Cryptography

An Efficient Identity-Based Conditional Privacy-Preserving Authentication Scheme for Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks

Efficient access control scheme for heterogeneous signcryption based on blockchain in VANETs

A Lightweight CP-ABE Scheme with Direct Attribute Revocation for Vehicular Ad Hoc Network