Abstract:Recent studies have provided empirical evidence on the prognostic relevance of objective performance diagnostics in the soccer talent identification and development process. However, little is known about the prognostic validity of coaches' subjective evaluations of performance. This study evaluated objective and subjective assessments within a nationwide talent development program and addressed motor, perceptual skill, and personality-related performance factors. Male players (N = 13,869; M age = 12.59 ± 1.07 years) from the age groups U12 to U15 of the German soccer talent development program participated in this study. Participants completed an objective motor diagnostic (sprint, agility, dribbling, ball control, juggling) and were subjectively rated by their coaches (kicking skills, endurance, individual tactical skills, psychosocial skills). All nine predictors were assessed with sufficient psychometric properties (α ≥ 0.72; except dribbling and ball control: α ≥ 0.53). Players' success three seasons later was operationalized by achieving professional youth academy level or not (success rate, 9%). Independent-samples t-tests analyzed univariate mean group comparisons between future selected and non-selected players. Logistic regression models examined the multivariate prognostic validity of all assessments by predicting success with subjective (model 1), objective (model 2), and both groups of predictors (model 3). Confirming the univariate prognostic validity, future selected outperformed non-selected players regarding all predictors (each p < 0.001, except for agility in U15: p < 0.01). Tactical skills, kicking skills, and sprint were of highest predictive value (d ≥ 0.61 in each age group). Multivariate results provided empirical evidence for the subjective (7% ≤ Nagelkerke's R 2 ≤ 11%; each p < 0.001) and objective (8% ≤ Nagelkerke's R 2 ≤ 13%; each p < 0.001) assessments' prognostic validity. However, model 3 revealed the best statistical explanatory power in each age group (0.15 ≤ Nagelkerke's R 2 ≤ 0.20; p < 0.001). In this combined assessment model, sprint, tactical skills, and dribbling were found to be the most predictive variables. In conclusion, this study reinforces the call for multidimensional diagnostics integrating objective and subjective assessments. Future research is needed to address the demands for longitudinal analyses of subjective ratings, the integration of biological maturation, and empirical evidence for female soccer.

"Who's Got Talent?" Change of Direction, Anthropometric Characteristics and Maturity Offset Differences Between Elite and Sub-Elite Young Soccer Player

No Impact of Anthropometric and Fitness Factors on Speed–Agility in Young Soccer Players: Is It a Cognitive Influence?

Anthropometric, body composition and physical performance of elite young Italian football players and differences between selected and unselected talents

Assessment of Body Composition and Physical Performance of Young Soccer Players: Differences According to the Competitive Level

Reliability of Change of Direction and Agility Assessments in Youth Soccer Players

What Factors Discriminate Young Soccer Players Perceived as Promising and Less Promising by Their Coaches?

Assessment of Performance in Youth Soccer Players: Should We Consider the Maturation Status?

Differences in Maturity and Anthropometric and Morphological Characteristics among Young Male Basketball and Soccer Players and Non-Players

Talent identification in soccer: The influence of technical, physical and maturity-related characteristics on a national selection process

Soccer Player Characteristics in English Lower-League Development Programmes: The Relationships between Relative Age, Maturation, Anthropometry and Physical Fitness

Age-Related Differences in Fitness Performance and Technical Skills of Young Soccer Players

Evaluation of multi-directional speed qualities throughout adolescence in youth soccer: The non-linear nature of transfer

Longitudinal Physical Development of Future Professional Male Soccer Players: Implications for Talent Identification and Development?

Age-Related Differences in the Anthropometric and Physical Fitness Characteristics of Young Soccer Players: A Cross-Sectional Study

Effect of maturation level on normative specific-agility performance metrics and their fitness predictors in soccer players aged 11–18 years

Age and Maturation Matter in Youth Elite Soccer, but Depending on Competitive Level and Gender

Things to keep in mind when selecting physical assessments in youth soccer: Correlations between test performances, interlimb asymmetries, and effects of maturation

Youth soccer players, 11–14 years: Maturity, size, function, skill and goal orientation

Physical Characteristics of Elite Youth Female Soccer Players Characterized by Maturity Status

Selection-Dependent Differences in Youth Elite Basketball Players' Relative Age, Maturation-Related Characteristics, and Motor Performance

Nationwide Subjective and Objective Assessments of Potential Talent Predictors in Elite Youth Soccer: An Investigation of Prognostic Validity in a Prospective Study