Abstract:We have shown that accounting for microphysical variability and turbulence effects on temperature and vapour fields within mixed‐phase cloud parcels (via a stochastic Lagrangian representation of the microphysics) leads to more resilient mixed‐phase states compared with standard representations based on the mean‐field approximation. The conditional statistical distributions of the supersaturations over liquid water and ice shown in the figure are nearly Gaussian and sufficiently broad. A significant part of the droplet population experiences supersaturation and grows, even when the Wegener–Bergeron–Findeisen process operates in the bulk of the parcel (as ⟨Sl⟩l<0 and ⟨Si⟩i>0 ). This is an interesting feature behind the resilience of the liquid water content in mixed‐phase adiabatic parcels under certain idealised conditions. By assuming that liquid droplets and ice crystals within a computational grid box grow under the same conditions, mean‐field representations of mixed‐phase clouds in numerical models favour a quick cloud glaciation driven by the Wegener–Bergeron–Findeisen process. Consequently, maintenance of mixed‐phase states under the mean‐field approximation is conditioned to external dynamical forcing, such as sufficiently strong updraughts. In this work we go beyond the mean‐field representation and investigate the maintenance of mixed‐phase states in adiabatic (non‐entraining) cloud volumes by accounting for local variability in a particle's growth conditions in the turbulent cloud environment. This is done by using a Lagrangian microphysical scheme, where temperature and vapour mixing ratio are stochastic attributes attached to each cloud particle. Different dynamic scenarios show that microphysical variability and parametrised turbulence effects may significantly reduce cloud glaciation rates, resulting in much more resilient mixed‐phase states in idealised parcels containing non‐sedimenting and non‐aggregating cloud particles. We have stated a more refined criterion for the Wegener–Bergeron–Findeisen process activity in the bulk of a mixed‐phase cloud parcel (or computational grid box). This criterion is stated in terms of the conditional average supersaturations that are experienced by specific cloud particle types (liquid or ice), and not in terms of unconditional averages corresponding to parcel‐ or grid‐mean values of supersaturations. Formulation of a relation between conditional and unconditional average supersaturations poses an interesting closure problem in mixed‐phase cloud microphysics. Our stochastic microphysical model provides a Lagrangian closure to this problem and gives insights towards the development of a prognostic stochastic subgrid‐scale scheme for condensation/deposition in numerical models of mixed‐phase clouds.

Moist-entropic vertical adiabatic lapse rates: the standard cases and some lead towards inhomogeneous conditions

The mixed-phase version of moist-air entropy

Definition of a moist-air entropy potential temperature. Application to FIRE-I data flights

A summary of several meteorological properties of the moist-air entropy variables $θ_s$ and $PV(θ_s)$

Comments on "MSE minus CAPE is the True Conserved Variable for an Adiabatically Lifted Parcel"

On the computation of moist-air specific thermal enthalpy

Reappraising the appropriate calculation of a common meteorological quantity: Potential Temperature.

A variational method for estimating surface fluxes with mass conservation constraint

Persistent mixed‐phase states in adiabatic cloud parcels under idealised conditions

Application of the second law to the atmosphere: impacts of the third-law definition for the moist-air entropy

Thermodynamic consistency and structure-preservation in summation by parts methods for the moist compressible Euler equations

Adiabatic lapse rate of non-ideal gases: The role of molecular interactions and vibrations

A consistent treatment of mixed‐phase saturation for atmospheric thermodynamics

On the accuracy with which the lower boundary conditions can be determined in numerical models of the atmosphere

Water vapor transport to material surfaces-Simplified analytical expressions for non-linear material properties

A Third-Law Isentropic Analysis of a Simulated Hurricane

Asymptotics for moist deep convection I: Refined scalings and self-sustaining updrafts

The advection-condensation model and water vapour PDFs

New Results on the Thermodynamical Properties of the Climate System

The Vertical Profile of Radiative Cooling and Lapse Rate in a Warming Climate

Steady-state supersaturation distributions for clouds under turbulent forcing