Observational confirmation of the Sun's CNO cycle

Michael Mozina,Hilton Ratcliffe,O. Manuel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0512633

2007-04-29

Abstract:Gamma rays from a solar flare in Active Region 10039 on 23 July 2002 with the RHESSI spacecraft spectrometer indicate that the CNO cycle occurs at the solar surface, in electrical discharges along closed magnetic loops. At the two feet of the loop, H ions are accelerated to energy levels that surpass Coulomb barriers for the C-12[H-1, gamma]N-13 and N-14[H-1, gamma]O-15 reactions. First x-rays appear along the discharge path. Next annihilation of positrons from N-13 and O-15 [half-life = 10 m and 2 m] produce bright spots of 0.511 MeV gammas at the loop feet. As C-13 increases from positron decay of N-13, the C-13[He-4, n]O-16 reaction produces neutrons and then the 2.2 MeV emission line appears from n-capture on H-1. These results suggest that the CNO cycle changed the N-15/N-14 ratio in the solar wind and at the solar surface over geologic time, and this ratio may contain an important historical record of climate changes related to sunspot activity.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of whether the solar CNO cycle (carbon - nitrogen - oxygen cycle) occurs on the solar surface. Specifically, by observing gamma rays in a solar flare event in solar active region 10039 on July 23, 2002, the author verified that the CNO cycle may occur in the ionized discharge loops on the solar surface.

### Core issues of the paper:
1. **Contradiction between traditional views and new findings**:
- The traditional view is that the CNO cycle mainly occurs in the solar core as one of the main ways for hydrogen to fuse into helium.
- New observational results indicate that the CNO cycle may occur in magnetic loops near the solar surface, especially during solar flares.

2. **Changes in the nitrogen isotope ratio in the solar wind**:
- It has been observed that the \( ^{15}\text{N} / ^{14}\text{N} \) ratio in the solar wind changes over time, and this change is related to sunspot activity.
- These changes imply that the CNO cycle on the solar surface may have an impact on the composition of the solar wind and may record the history of climate change related to solar activity.

### Main research contents:
- **Observation data**: X - rays and gamma rays in solar flares were observed using the spectrometer of the RHESSI (Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager) spacecraft.
- **Reaction processes**:
- At the two footpoints of the magnetic loop, H⁺ ions are accelerated to an energy level sufficient to overcome the Coulomb barrier, and the following reactions occur:
\[
^{12}\text{C} + ^1\text{H} \rightarrow ^{13}\text{N} + \gamma
\]
\[
^{14}\text{N} + ^1\text{H} \rightarrow ^{15}\text{O} + \gamma
\]
- \( ^{13}\text{N} \) and \( ^{15}\text{O} \) have half - lives of 10 minutes and 2 minutes respectively. Their β⁺ decays produce positrons, and these positrons annihilate with electrons to produce 0.511 MeV gamma rays.
- Subsequently, \( ^{13}\text{N} \) decays into \( ^{13}\text{C} \), and the latter reacts with alpha particles to generate neutrons:
\[
^{13}\text{C} + \alpha \rightarrow ^{16}\text{O} + n
\]
- The neutron is captured on a hydrogen atom, producing a 2.2 MeV gamma ray:
\[
n + ^1\text{H} \rightarrow ^2\text{H} + \gamma (2.223 \, \text{MeV})
\]

### Conclusions:
- Based on these observational results, the author proposes that the CNO cycle occurs not only in the solar core but also in the ionized discharge loops on the solar surface.
- The CNO cycle on the solar surface may have affected the nitrogen isotope ratio in the solar wind, and this change is related to sunspot activity and may reflect the impact of solar activity on the climate.

In conclusion, through detailed observational data and theoretical analysis, this paper challenges the traditional view of the CNO cycle inside the sun and proposes a new possibility of the occurrence of the CNO cycle on the solar surface.