Abstract:Utilizing the methods of chiral effective field theory we present an analysis of the electromagnetic $N\Delta$-transition current in the framework of the non-relativistic "small scale expansion" (SSE) to leading-one-loop order. We discuss the momentum dependence of the magnetic dipole, electric quadrupole and coulomb quadrupole transition form factors up to a momentum transfer of $Q^2<0.3$ GeV$^2$. Particular emphasis is put on the identification of the role of chiral dynamics in this transition. Our analysis indicates that there is indeed non-trivial momentum dependence in the two quadrupole form factors at small $Q^2<0.15$ GeV$^2$ arising from long distance pion physics, leading for example to negative radii in the (real part of the) quadrupole transition form factors. We compare our results with the EMR($Q^2$) and CMR($Q^2$) multipole-ratios from pion-electroproduction experiments and find a remarkable agreement up to four-momentum transfer of $Q^2\approx 0.3$ GeV$^2$. Finally, we discuss the chiral extrapolation of the three transition form factors at $Q^2=0$, identifying rapid changes in the (real part of the) quark-mass dependence of the quadrupole transition moments for pion masses below 200 MeV, which arise again from long distance pion dynamics. Our findings indicate that dipole extrapolation methods currently used in lattice QCD analyses of baryon form factors are not applicable for the chiral extrapolation of $N\Delta$ quadrupole transition form factors.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the characteristics of the electromagnetic transition current in the nucleon - to - Delta (N∆) transition process, especially to identify the chiral dynamics at work in this transition. Specifically, the author uses the chiral effective field theory (Chiral Effective Field Theory, ChEFT) within the framework of the non - relativistic "Small Scale Expansion" (Small Scale Expansion, SSE) to analyze the electromagnetic transition current in the N∆ transition, with a focus on the momentum dependence of the magnetic dipole, electric quadrupole, and Coulomb quadrupole transition form factors. ### Main problems and goals: 1. **Study the electromagnetic transition current in the N∆ transition**: - Analyze the electromagnetic transition current in the N∆ transition through the ChEFT method, especially in the SSE framework. - Focus on the behavior of these form factors at low momentum transfer $ Q^2 < 0.3 \, \text{GeV}^2 $. 2. **Identify the role of chiral dynamics**: - Emphasize the influence of long - range pion physics on chiral dynamics, especially the non - trivial momentum dependence observed at low $ Q^2 $. - Pay special attention to the negative - radius phenomenon exhibited by the quadrupole transition form factors at low $ Q^2 $. 3. **Compare experimental results**: - Compare the calculated results with the EMR and CMR multipole ratios in the π - electroproduction experiment to verify the validity of the theoretical model. - Study the momentum dependence of the quadrupole transition form factors at $ Q^2 \approx 0.3 \, \text{GeV}^2 $. 4. **Explore the chiral extrapolation problem**: - Discuss the chiral extrapolation of the three transition form factors at $ Q^2 = 0 $, especially the changes when the pion mass is below 200 MeV. - Point out that the dipole extrapolation method currently used for lattice QCD analysis is not suitable for the chiral extrapolation of the N∆ quadrupole transition form factors. ### Formula presentation: To ensure the correctness and readability of the formulas, the following are some key formulas involved in the paper: - Definitions of the magnetic dipole, electric quadrupole, and Coulomb quadrupole transition form factors: \[ G_M^*(q^2) = \frac{M_N}{3(M_N + M_\Delta)} \left[ \left( \frac{(3M_\Delta + M_N)(M_\Delta + M_N) - q^2}{2M_N M_\Delta} \right) G_1^\dagger(q^2) - \left( \frac{M_\Delta^2 - M_N^2 - q^2}{4M_N^2} \right) G_2^\dagger(q^2) - \frac{q^2}{2M_N \Delta} G_3^\dagger(q^2) \right] \] \[ G_E^*(q^2) = \frac{M_N}{3(M_N + M_\Delta)} \left[ \left( \frac{M_\Delta^2 - M_N^2 + q^2}{2M_N M_\Delta} \right) G_1^\dagger(q^2) - \left( \frac{M_\Delta^2 - M_N^2 - q^2}{4M_N^2} \right) G_2^\dagger(q^2) - \frac{q^2}{2M_N \Delta} G_3^\dagger(q^2) \right] \] \[ G_C^*(q^2) = \frac{2M_N}{3(M_N + M_\Delta)} \left[ \left( \frac{M_\Delta}{M_N} \right) G_1^\dagger(q^2) - \left( \frac{M_\Delta^2 + M_N^2 - q^2}{4M_N^2} \right) G_2^\dagger(q^2) - \frac{q^2}{2M_N \Delta} G_3^\dagger(q^2) \right]

Signatures of chiral dynamics in the Nucleon to Delta transition

Non-perturbative Chiral Corrections for Lattice QCD

Chiral Effective Field Theories with explicit Spin 3/2 Degrees of Freedom---A Status Report

Electromagnetic form factors of the transition from the Delta to the nucleon

Nucleon Magnetic Moments Beyond the Perturbative Chiral Regime

Nucleon and $${\delta}$$ Δ Elastic and Transition Form Factors

Nucleon and Δ Elastic and Transition Form Factors

Pion-Nucleon Scattering and the Pi-Nn Coupling-Constant in the Chiral Color-Dielectric Model

Elastic pion-nucleon scattering in chiral perturbation theory: Explicit $Δ$(1232) degrees of freedom

Chiral properties of the nucleon interpolating current and -dependent observables

Chiral Behavior of K →π L Ν Decay Form Factors in Lattice QCD with Exact Chiral Symmetry

Chiral dynamics in the low-temperature phase of QCD

Recent results in chiral effective field theory for the NN system

Chiral properties of the nucleon interpolating current and $θ$-dependent observables

Electromagnetic moments of quasi-stable baryons

Nucleon-to-Roper electromagnetic transition form factors at large-$Q^2$

The role of intermediate $ΔΔ$ states in nucleon-nucleon scattering in the large-$N_c$ and unitary limits, and $ΔΔ$ and $ΩΩ$ scattering

Unified study of nucleon and $Δ$ baryon spectra and their strong decays with chiral dynamics

Nucleon Spin Sum Rules and Spin Polarizabilities at low $Q^2$

Nuclear chiral dynamics and phases of QCD

The reaction pi N -> pi pi N in chiral effective field theory with explicit Delta(1232) degrees of freedom