Bimodal Galaxies and Bimodality in Globular Cluster Systems

Duncan A. Forbes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/499563

2005-11-10

Abstract:Various galaxy properties are not continuous over a large range in mass, but rather reveal a remarkable transition or `bimodality' at a stellar mass of 3 x 10^{10} Mo. These properties include colors, stellar populations, Xray emission and mass-to-light ratios. This behavior has been interpreted as the transition from hot to cold flows by Dekel & Birnboim (2005). Here we explore whether globular cluster (GC) systems also reveal a bimodal nature with regard to this critical mass scale. Globular clusters probe star formation at early epochs in the Universe and survive subsequent galaxy mergers and accretions. We use new data from the ACS Virgo Cluster Survey (Peng etal 2005), which provides a homogeneous sample of the GC systems around one hundred Virgo early-type galaxies covering a range of five hundred in galaxy mass. Their classification of the GC color distributions is taken to examine a key quantity -- the number of GCs per unit galaxy luminosity. Below the critical mass, this quantity (called the GC specific frequency) increases dramatically in its mean value and spread. This increase may be due to regulated star formation in low mass galaxies, which in turn is due to mass loss via winds and the transition from hot to cold gas accretion flows. We also note that above the critical mass, galaxies possess two GC subpopulations (with blue and red mean colors) but below this mass, galaxies reveal an increasing proportion of single (blue) GC systems.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether Globular Cluster Systems (GCs) exhibit bimodality at the critical stellar mass (about \(3\times 10^{10}M_{\odot}\)) and are consistent with the property changes of the general galaxy population. Specifically, the author has studied the following issues:

1. **Bimodality of Globular Cluster Systems**: Do the number and characteristics of globular clusters show significant differences above and below the critical stellar mass? For example, does the specific frequency (\(S_N\)) change with the change of stellar mass?
2. **Bimodality of Color Distribution**: Are the color distributions of globular clusters different above and below the critical stellar mass? Do high - mass galaxies have two sub - populations (blue and red), while low - mass galaxies are mainly monochromatic (mainly blue)?
3. **Early Galaxy Formation and Evolution**: As probes of star formation in the early universe, can the characteristics of globular clusters reveal the formation and evolution paths of galaxies of different masses in the early stage?

### Key Findings

- **Bimodality at the Critical Stellar Mass**: At the critical stellar mass of \(3\times 10^{10}M_{\odot}\), various properties of galaxies (such as color, stellar population, X - ray emission, etc.) show obvious bimodality.
- **Change in the Specific Frequency of Globular Clusters**: For galaxies below the critical stellar mass, the specific frequency (\(S_N\)) of globular clusters shows a large range of variation and increases as the mass decreases; for galaxies above the critical stellar mass, the specific frequency is relatively stable.
- **Difference in Color Distribution**: Galaxies above the critical stellar mass usually have two - colored globular clusters (blue and red), while galaxies below the critical stellar mass are more likely to show a single blue globular cluster.

### Formula Representation

The specific frequency (specific frequency, \(S_N\)) of globular clusters is defined as the number of globular clusters per unit galaxy luminosity, and the formula is as follows:

\[ S_N=f\times N_{GC}\times 10^{0.4(M_V + 15)} \]

where:
- \(f\) is the proportion of blue or red globular clusters,
- \(N_{GC}\) is the total number of globular clusters,
- \(M_V\) is the absolute V - band magnitude of the galaxy.

The specific frequencies for blue and red globular clusters are respectively:

\[ S_{N,\text{blue}}=f_{\text{blue}}\times N_{GC}\times 10^{0.4(M_V + 15)} \]
\[ S_{N,\text{red}}=f_{\text{red}}\times N_{GC}\times 10^{0.4(M_V + 15)} \]

These formulas help to quantify the distribution of globular cluster systems in galaxies of different masses.

Through these studies, the author hopes to understand the relationship between globular cluster systems and the overall properties of galaxies, thereby further revealing the physical mechanisms of galaxy formation and evolution.