Spectrophotometric properties of galaxies at intermediate redshifts (z ~ 0.2--1.0) II. The Luminosity -- Metallicity relation

Fabrice Lamareille,Thierry Contini,Jarle Brinchmann,Jean-François Le Borgne,Stéphane Charlot,Johan Richard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%3A20053602

2005-11-24

Abstract:We present the gas-phase oxygen abundance (O/H) for a sample of 131 star-forming galaxies at intermediate redshifts ($0.2<z<1.0$). The sample selection, the spectroscopic observations (mainly with VLT/FORS) and associated data reduction, the photometric properties, the emission-line measurements, and the spectral classification are fully described in a companion paper (Paper I). We use two methods to estimate the O/H abundance ratio: the {} "standard" $R\_{\mathrm{23}}$ method which is based on empirical calibrations, and the CL01 method which is based on grids of photo-ionization models and on the fitting of emission lines. For most galaxies, we have been able to solve the problem of the metallicity degeneracy between the high- and low-metallicity branches of the O/H vs. $R\_{\mathrm{23}}$ relationship using various secondary indicators. The luminosity -- metallicity ($L-Z$) relation has been derived in the $B$- and $R$-bands, with metallicities derived with the two methods ($R\_{\mathrm{23}}$ and CL01). In the analysis, we first consider our sample alone and then a larger one which includes other samples of intermediate-redshift galaxies drawn from the literature. The derived $L-Z$ relations at intermediate redshifts are very similar (same slope) to the $L-Z$ relation obtained for the local universe. Our sample alone only shows a small evolution of the $L-Z$ relation with redshift up to $z\sim1.0$. We only find statistical variations consistent with the uncertainty in the derived parameters. Including other samples of intermediate-redshift galaxies, we find however that galaxies at $z\sim1$ appear to be metal-deficient by a factor of $\sim3$ compared with galaxies in the local universe. For a given luminosity, they contain on average about one third of the metals locked in local galaxies.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore the luminosity - metallicity relationship (L - Z relationship) of galaxies at intermediate redshifts ($0.2 < z < 1.0$) and study the evolution of this relationship at different redshifts. Specifically, the author hopes to solve the problems through the following points:

1. **Determine the gas - phase oxygen abundance of galaxies at intermediate redshifts**:
- The researchers estimated the gas - phase oxygen abundances (O/H) of 131 star - forming galaxies by two methods: the standard R23 method and the CL01 method based on photoionization models.
- The sample selection, spectral observations (mainly using VLT/FORS), data processing, luminosity properties, emission line measurements, and spectral classification of these galaxies have been described in detail in the accompanying paper (Paper I).

2. **Solve the double - valued problem of metallicity**:
- Since there is a double - valued relationship (i.e., high - metallicity and low - metallicity branches) between the R23 parameter and oxygen abundance, the researchers used multiple auxiliary indicators to solve this problem.
- For example, the N2 diagnostic method ([N II] λ6584 / Hα) and the L diagnostic method (based on the L - Z relationship itself) were used to distinguish between high - metallicity and low - metallicity galaxies.

3. **Study the evolution of the L - Z relationship**:
- The author first analyzed their own sample and then combined it with samples of intermediate - redshift galaxies from other literature to evaluate the change of the L - Z relationship with redshift.
- The results show that in the B - band and R - band, the L - Z relationship of intermediate - redshift galaxies is very similar (the same slope) to that in the local universe. But when combined with other samples, it was found that galaxies at a redshift of about 1 are about 3 times more metal - poor than galaxies in the local universe.

### Key conclusions

- **Similarity of the L - Z relationship**: For galaxies with redshifts less than 1, the L - Z relationship is basically the same as that in the local universe, with the same slope.
- **Evolution of metallicity**: Although the individual sample shows no significant change, when combined with other samples, it was found that the average metallicity of galaxies at a redshift of about 1 is only one - third of that of galaxies in the local universe.
- **Method verification**: The results of the two methods for estimating oxygen abundance (R23 and CL01) are relatively consistent, and the double - valued problem of metallicity has been successfully solved by multiple means.

These research results are helpful for understanding the chemical evolution of galaxies and their changes on the cosmic time scale.