Fractal Dimensions in Perceptual Color Space: A Comparison Study Using Jackson Pollock's Art

J. R. Mureika

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2121947

2005-09-18

Abstract:The fractal dimensions of color-specific paint patterns in various Jackson Pollock paintings are calculated using a filtering process which models perceptual response to color differences ($\Lab$ color space). The advantage of the $\Lab$ space filtering method over traditional RGB spaces is that the former is a perceptually-uniform (metric) space, leading to a more consistent definition of ``perceptually different'' colors. It is determined that the RGB filtering method underestimates the perceived fractal dimension of lighter colored patterns but not of darker ones, if the same selection criteria is applied to each. Implications of the findings to Fechner's 'Principle of the Aesthetic Middle' and Berlyne's work on perception of complexity are discussed.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to calculate and understand the fractal dimensions of different color patterns in Jackson Pollock's paintings more accurately, especially their performance in the perceptual color space. Specifically, the paper explores the use of the perceptually uniform CIE - L*a*b* color space (instead of the traditional RGB color space) to filter and analyze the color patterns in Pollock's paintings, so as to better reflect the perceptual differences of colors in the human visual system.

### Main problems:
1. **Choice of color space**: The traditional RGB color space has limitations when analyzing color patterns because it is not a perceptually uniform space. This means that colors that seem similar in the RGB space may have significant differences in human visual perception.

2. **Calculation of fractal dimension**: The paper aims to recalculate the fractal dimensions of different color patterns in Pollock's paintings by using the perceptually uniform L*a*b* color space and compare the results with those in the RGB space. This helps to understand the complexity and aesthetic value of these patterns more accurately.

3. **Relationship between aesthetics and perception**: The paper also explores the relationship between these fractal dimensions and aesthetic theories (such as Fechner's "aesthetic median principle" and Berlyne's work on complexity perception), especially why some fractal dimensions may be more attractive than others.

### Specific objectives:
- **Verify the limitations of the RGB color space**: By comparing the fractal dimensions in the RGB and L*a*b* color space, prove that the RGB space underestimates the perceived fractal dimension when dealing with light - colored patterns.

- **Explore the advantages of the perceptually uniform color space**: Show that the L*a*b* color space can capture the perceptual differences of colors in the human visual system more accurately, especially when dealing with light - colored and dark - colored patterns.

- **Discuss the relationship between artistic creation and perception**: Explore whether Pollock attracts the audience's attention by choosing specific fractal structures and how these structures affect the audience's emotional response.

### Summary:
The core problem of the paper is to calculate and interpret the fractal dimensions in Pollock's paintings more accurately by improving the choice of color space, thereby revealing the complexity and aesthetic significance of these patterns in human perception.