The Evidence of Absence: Galaxy Voids in the Excursion Set Formalism

Steven Furlanetto,Tsvi Piran

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2005.09862.x

2005-11-22

Abstract:We present an analytic model for the sizes of voids in the galaxy distribution. Peebles and others have recently emphasized the possibility that the observed characteristics of voids may point to a problem in galaxy formation models, but testing these claims has been difficult without any clear predictions for their properties. In order to address such questions, we build a model to describe the distribution of galaxy underdensities. Our model is based on the "excursion set formalism," the same technique used to predict the dark matter halo mass function. We find that, because of bias, galaxy voids are typically significantly larger than dark matter voids and should fill most of the universe. We show that voids selected from catalogs of luminous galaxies should be larger than those selected from faint galaxies: the characteristic radii range from ~5-10h^{-1} Mpc for galaxies with absolute r-band magnitudes M_r-5 log(h) < -16 to -20. These are reasonably close to, though somewhat smaller than, the observed sizes. The discrepancy may result from the void selection algorithm or from their internal structure. We also compute the halo populations inside voids. We expect small haloes (M<10^{11} Msun) to be up to a factor of two less underdense than the haloes of normal galaxies. Within large voids, the mass function is nearly independent of the size of the underdensity, but finite-size effects play a significant role in small voids (R<7h^{-1} Mpc).

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to solve the problem of the differences between theoretical models and observational results regarding the characteristics of galaxy voids in cosmology. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Size distribution of galaxy voids**: Current cosmological structure formation models (such as the Cold Dark Matter model, CDM) can explain many features of galaxy distribution, but are insufficient in predicting the characteristics of voids. The author attempts to establish an analytical model to describe the size distribution of galaxy voids.

2. **Relationship between galaxy voids and dark matter voids**: Since galaxies are biased with respect to dark matter, galaxy voids are usually larger than dark matter voids and occupy most of the cosmic space. The author hopes to reveal this relationship through their model.

3. **Influence of different - luminosity galaxies on void size**: Voids selected from bright galaxy catalogs are usually larger than those selected from faint galaxies. The author analyzes the reasons for this phenomenon and gives the typical radius ranges for different absolute r - band magnitudes (Mr−5logh).

4. **Distribution of halo populations inside voids**: The author also calculates the distribution of low - mass halo populations inside voids and finds that the number of low - mass halo populations is less than that of normal galaxy halo populations, especially in large voids, and the mass function of halo populations hardly depends on the size of the under - density.

5. **Comparison between theory and observation**: Through the established model, the author generates a baseline prediction to compare with the observed void characteristics. They find that the void radius predicted by the model is slightly smaller than the observational results, which may be due to the void selection algorithm or its internal structure.

### Summary

The main goal of the paper is to construct an analytical model through the "excursion set formalism" to describe the distribution of galaxy voids and the characteristics of halo populations inside them. This model not only helps to understand the void phenomenon in the CDM framework, but also provides a theoretical basis for future observations and simulations.