Abstract:We test for evidence violating the duality invariant ratio of photon beam irradiance and wave intensity. Split beams from a 633 nm HeNe laser are intersected at a diffraction grating complementary to the resultant interference pattern. An output beam from the grating, depleted in irradiance relative to wave intensity from the perspective of local realism, is transiently intersected with a beam from an independent HeNe laser and measured irradiance is amplified by ~4% in conflict with quantum mechanics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the difference in the duality of photon beams (wave - particle duality) within the frameworks of local realism and quantum mechanics. Specifically, the author aims to verify through experimental tests whether a phenomenon consistent with the predictions of local realism but contrary to quantum mechanics can be produced in the continuous - wave domain.
### Overview of Main Problems
1. **Theoretical Background**:
- In quantum mechanics, photons are regarded as probabilistic entities with wave or particle properties, and the proportional relationship between their wave intensity ($W$) and energy flux density ($I$) is fixed, and a photon can only interfere with itself.
- In local realism, photons are composed of independent wave structures and energy quanta. The wave intensity is a relative probability density, and wave entities do not interact with each other. Therefore, the wave intensity and energy flux density can have different relationships, allowing photons to exhibit different behaviors under different conditions.
2. **Experimental Objectives**:
- By preparing a photon beam in a state where the energy flux density ($I$) is reduced relative to the wave intensity ($W$) (i.e., the "depleted" state), and then briefly coupling this beam with another ordinary beam, observe whether the expected redistribution of energy quanta will occur.
- If this redistribution occurs, it supports local realism; if it does not occur, it conforms to the predictions of quantum mechanics.
3. **Key Concepts**:
- **Occupation Value**: Defined as $\Omega=\frac{I}{W}$, where $I$ is the energy flux density (irradiance) and $W$ is the wave intensity (wave intensity). For quantum mechanics, $\Omega$ should be a constant; for local realism, $\Omega$ can be different from a constant.
- **Experimental Design**: Use two coherent beams to interfere through a diffraction grating, adjust the beam paths so that the energy flux density of the output beam is reduced relative to the wave intensity, and then couple it with another independent beam and measure the change in light intensity after coupling.
4. **Experimental Results**:
- The experimental results show that when using a specific grating (Gc), the coupled beam does show an approximately 4% increase in energy flux density, which is consistent with the predictions of local realism and contrary to the predictions of quantum mechanics.
- When using another grating (Gu), the experimental results are close to the predictions of quantum mechanics, indicating that this difference can be amplified by choosing different grating structures.
### Summary
The main purpose of this paper is to experimentally verify the differences between local realism and quantum mechanics in the duality of photon beams. The experimental results show that under certain conditions, the behavior of photon beams is more in line with the predictions of local realism, thus providing a new perspective for understanding the physical nature of the microscopic world.