The Hydraulic Jump in Liquid Helium

Etienne Rolley,Claude Guthmann,Michael S. Pettersen,Christophe Chevallier

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2354642

2005-08-30

Abstract:We present the results of some experiments on the circular hydraulic jump in normal and superfluid liquid helium. The radius of the jump and the depth of the liquid outside the jump are measured through optical means. Although the scale of the apparatus is rather small, the location of the jump is found to be consistent with the assumption that the jump can be treated as a shock, if the surface tension is taken into account. The radius of the jump does not change when going down in temperature through the lambda point; we think that the flow is supercritical. A remarkable feature of the experiment is the observation of stationary ripples within the jump when the liquid is superfluid.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the characteristics of hydraulic jump in liquid helium and its behavioral differences between the superfluid and normal states. Specifically, the researchers explored the following issues through experiments:

1. **Measurement of the position of hydraulic jump and liquid depth**: The researchers used optical means to measure the radius \(R_j\) of the hydraulic jump and the depth \(d\) of the liquid outside the jump, in order to verify whether the hydraulic jump can be explained by shock - wave theory and consider the influence of surface tension.

2. **The influence of temperature change on hydraulic jump**: The researchers observed the change in the position of the hydraulic jump when the temperature dropped below the lambda point, especially whether there were significant changes during the transition from the normal state to the superfluid state.

3. **Special phenomena in the superfluid state**: The researchers paid special attention to the stationary ripple phenomenon observed in the superfluid state and attempted to explain the causes of these ripples and their relationship with the liquid depth.

### Main findings

- **Validity of the shock - wave model**: The experimental results show that, if the influence of surface tension is considered, the hydraulic jump can be regarded as a shock wave. The models of Watson and Bush - Aristoff overestimated and underestimated the experimental results respectively, but generally support the shock - wave theory.

- Watson model:
\[
R_j=\left(\frac{Q^2}{g h_0^5}\right)^{1/6}
\]
- Bush and Aristoff model:
\[
R_j=\left(\frac{Q^2}{g h_0^5}\right)^{1/6}\cdot\left(1 + \frac{\sigma}{\rho g h_0^2}\right)
\]
where \(Q\) is the flow rate, \(g\) is the acceleration due to gravity, \(h_0\) is the initial liquid depth, \(\sigma\) is the surface tension, and \(\rho\) is the liquid density.

- **No significant change below the lambda point**: Even when the temperature dropped below the lambda point, the radius of the hydraulic jump did not change significantly. The researchers believe that this may be due to the fact that the fluid velocity exceeds the critical velocity of superfluidity.

- **Stationary ripples in the superfluid state**: In the superfluid state, stationary ripples were observed in the experiment. These ripples can be explained as waves generated inside the jump and propagating upstream. By assuming that the phase velocity of shallow - water capillary waves is equal to the fluid velocity, the liquid depth inside the jump was estimated to be approximately 10 micrometers.

### Conclusion

The research results show that the hydraulic jump can be explained by shock - wave theory, and surface tension plays an important role in small - scale experiments. Although no obvious jump was observed below the lambda point, a special stationary ripple phenomenon occurred in the superfluid state, which may be related to the lower viscosity. Further research is analyzing the specific mechanisms of these phenomena.