Glassy Dynamics in the Adaptive Immune Response Prevents Autoimmune Disease

Jun Sun,David J. Earl,Michael W. Deem

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.95.148104

2005-08-17

Abstract:The immune system normally protects the human host against death by infection. However, when an immune response is mistakenly directed at self antigens, autoimmune disease can occur. We describe a model of protein evolution to simulate the dynamics of the adaptive immune response to antigens. Computer simulations of the dynamics of antibody evolution show that different evolutionary mechanisms, namely gene segment swapping and point mutation, lead to different evolved antibody binding affinities. Although a combination of gene segment swapping and point mutation can yield a greater affinity to a specific antigen than point mutation alone, the antibodies so evolved are highly cross-reactive and would cause autoimmune disease, and this is not the chosen dynamics of the immune system. We suggest that in the immune system a balance has evolved between binding affinity and specificity in the mechanism for searching the amino acid sequence space of antibodies.

Populations and Evolution,Statistical Mechanics,Biological Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to understand the working mechanism of the immune system in preventing autoimmune diseases by simulating the dynamics of the adaptive immune response**. Specifically, the author explored the effects of different evolutionary mechanisms (such as gene segment exchange and point mutation) on antibody affinity and its specificity, and explained why the immune system has chosen a specific balance strategy to optimize the binding of antibodies to antigens while avoiding the occurrence of autoimmune diseases.

### Main research content

1. **Model description**:
- The author constructed a model of protein evolution to simulate the dynamic changes of antibodies against antigens in the adaptive immune response.
- Two different evolutionary strategies were used in the model: point mutation only (PM) and point mutation plus gene segment exchange (GSS + PM).

2. **Experimental results**:
- **Affinity improvement**: Through computer simulation, it was found that the GSS + PM strategy can generate antibodies with higher affinity, but these antibodies are also more likely to cross - react, thereby increasing the risk of autoimmune diseases.
- **Cross - reactivity**: Studies have shown that although the antibodies generated by the GSS + PM strategy have a higher affinity for specific antigens, they are also more likely to recognize other non - target antigens, resulting in greater cross - reactivity.

3. **Balance of the immune system**:
- The immune system has developed a balance mechanism during evolution, which can maintain the specificity of antibodies while increasing their affinity, so as to avoid the occurrence of autoimmune diseases.
- By calculating the cross - reactivity at different antigen distances, the author found that although the GSS + PM strategy can significantly improve antibody affinity, it will also make antibodies recognize more non - target antigens, increasing the risk of autoimmune diseases.

### Conclusion

This study reveals that the immune system has chosen a relatively "slower" kinetic mechanism (such as somatic hypermutation) rather than the more efficient GSS + PM strategy during evolution to ensure that antibodies can effectively recognize foreign antigens without misidentifying self - antigens, thereby avoiding the occurrence of autoimmune diseases. This balance mechanism is crucial for maintaining the normal function of the immune system.

### Mathematical formulas

- **Expression of interaction energy**:
\[
U=\sum_{i = 1}^{M}U_{\text{sd}}^{\alpha_i}+\sum_{i>j = 1}^{M}U_{\text{sd - sd}}^{ij}+\sum_{i = 1}^{P}U_c^i
\]
where:
- \(U_{\text{sd}}^{\alpha_i}\) represents the interaction energy within the secondary structure.
- \(U_{\text{sd - sd}}^{ij}\) represents the interaction energy between secondary structures.
- \(U_c^i\) represents the direct binding energy between antibodies and antigens.

- **Expression of binding constant**:
\[
K=\exp(a - b\langle U\rangle)
\]
where \(a\) and \(b\) are constants obtained by comparing with immunological data.

Through these formulas, the author quantitatively analyzed the effects of different evolutionary strategies on antibody affinity and specificity.