Abstract:Categorical data analysis of 2 × 2 contingency tables is extremely common, not least because they provide risk difference, risk ratio, odds ratio, and log odds statistics in medical research. A χ2 test analysis is most often used, although some researchers use likelihood ratio test (LRT) analysis. Does it matter which test is used? A review of the literature, examination of the theoretical foundations, and analyses of simulations and empirical data are used by this paper to argue that only the LRT should be used when we are interested in testing whether the binomial proportions are equal. This so-called test of independence is by far the most popular, meaning the χ2 test is widely misused. By contrast, the χ2 test should be reserved for where the data appear to match too closely a particular hypothesis (e.g., the null hypothesis), where the variance is of interest, and is less than expected. Low variance can be of interest in various scenarios, particularly in investigations of data integrity. Finally, it is argued that the evidential approach provides a consistent and coherent method that avoids the difficulties posed by significance testing. The approach facilitates the calculation of appropriate log likelihood ratios to suit our research aims, whether this is to test the proportions or to test the variance. The conclusions from this paper apply to larger contingency tables, including multi-way tables.

The Geometry of Statistical Models for Two-Way Contingency Tables with Fixed Odds Ratios

A Nonparametric Measure of Local Association for two-way Contingency Tables

Visualization for departures from symmetry with the power-divergence-type measure in two-way contingency tables

Identification of Nonresponse Mechanisms for Two-Way Contingency Tables

Generating contingency tables with fixed marginal probabilities and dependence structures described by loglinear models

Association and Simpson conversion in $2 \times 2 \times 2$ contingency tables

Analysis Of A Sequence Of Dependent 2 X 2 Tables

Visualizing departures from marginal homogeneity for square contingency tables with ordered categories

Random Transpositions on Contingency Tables

The quantification of Simpsons paradox and other contributions to contingency table theory

A Constructive Procedure for Modeling Categorical Variables: Log-Linear and Logit Models

Diagonals–Parameter Symmetry Model and Its Property for Square Contingency Tables with Ordinal Categories

Likelihood Ratio Test and the Evidential Approach for 2 × 2 Tables

The role of the geometric mean in case-control studies

Consecutive collapsibility of odds ratios over an ordinal background variable

Conditional Difference Asymmetry Model for Square Contingency Tables with Nominal Categories

Test for symmetry in $2 \times 2$ contingency tables with nonignorable nonresponses

Combining estimates of the odds ratio: the state of the art

Formulas, Algorithms and Examples for Binomial Distributed Data Confidence Interval Calculation: Excess Risk, Relative Risk and Odds Ratio

Applicability of chi-square to 2???2 contingency tables with small expected cell frequencies.

Identification of Graphical Models for Nonignorable Nonresponse in Terms of Information on Odds Ratios