On the Submillimeter Opacity of Protoplanetary Disks

B.T. Draine

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/498130

2005-07-13

Abstract:Solid particles with the composition of interstellar dust and power-law size distribution dn/da propto a^{-p} for a < a_max with a_{max} > 3 lambda and 3 < p < 4 will have submm opacity spectral index beta(lambda) = dln(kappa)/dln(nu) approx (p-3) beta_{ism}, where beta_{ism} approx 1.7 is the opacity spectral index of interstellar dust material in the Rayleigh limit. For the power-law index p approx 3.5 that characterizes interstellar dust, and that appears likely for particles growing by agglomeration in protoplanetary disks, grain growth to sizes a > 3 mm will result in beta(1 mm) < ~1. Grain growth can naturally account for beta approx 1 observed for protoplanetary disks, provided that a_{max} > ~ 3 lambda.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Why is the sub - millimeter - band extinction spectral index \(\beta_{\text{disk}}\) of dust particles in the protoplanetary disk significantly lower than the spectral index \(\beta_{\text{ism}}\) of interstellar dust? Specifically, observations show that \(\beta_{\text{disk}}\approx1\) for the protoplanetary disk, while \(\beta_{\text{ism}}\approx1.7\) for interstellar dust. This difference needs to be explained.

### Main problems and background of the paper

1. **Observed phenomena**:
- For the protoplanetary disk, the usually observed spectral index is \(2 < \alpha < 3\), and the corresponding extinction spectral index \(\beta_{\text{disk}}\approx0.92\).
- For interstellar dust, far - infrared and sub - millimeter - band observations show that \(\beta_{\text{ism}}\approx1.7\).

2. **Possible explanations**:
- **Optical thickness**: Some regions are not optically thin in the millimeter - band.
- **Chemical composition**: The chemical composition of the particles in the disk is different from that of interstellar dust.
- **Particle geometry**: The particles in the disk may have a "fluffy" structure.
- **Particle growth**: The particles in the disk grow to a large enough size by coagulation so that they are no longer in the Rayleigh limit, resulting in a decrease in \(\beta\).

### Research methods

The author assumes that the solid particles in the protoplanetary disk follow a power - law distribution \(dn/da\propto a^{-p}\), where \(a\leq a_{\max}\) and \(3 < p < 4\). In this case, the extinction spectral index \(\beta\) can be approximated as:

\[ \beta\approx(p - 3)\beta_s\]

where \(\beta_s\) is the extinction spectral index of the material in the Rayleigh limit. For \(p\approx3.5\) and \(\beta_s\approx1.7\), if \(a_{\max}\gtrsim3\lambda\), then \(\beta\approx0.9\), which is consistent with the observational results.

### Conclusions

The main conclusion of the paper is that the growth of particles in the protoplanetary disk (i.e., the increase in particle size) can naturally explain the observed lower extinction spectral index \(\beta_{\text{disk}}\approx1\), without relying on compositional changes or special particle geometries. Specifically, when the particle size grows to \(a_{\max}\gtrsim3\lambda\), the power - law - distributed particles will lead to \(\beta\approx(p - 3)\beta_s\), thus explaining the observed \(\beta_{\text{disk}}< 1\).

Therefore, this paper mainly solves the problem of why the extinction spectral index \(\beta_{\text{disk}}\) in the protoplanetary disk is significantly lower than \(\beta_{\text{ism}}\) of interstellar dust, and proposes particle growth as a reasonable explanatory mechanism.