Interstitial gas and density-segregation in vertically-vibrated granular media

M. Klein,L. L. Tsai,M. S. Rosen,T. Pavlin,D. Candela,R. L. Walsworth

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.74.010301

2006-06-25

Abstract:We report experimental studies of the effect of interstitial gas on mass-density-segregation in a vertically-vibrated mixture of equal-sized bronze and glass spheres. Sufficiently strong vibration in the presence of interstitial gas induces vertical segregation into sharply separated bronze and glass layers. We find that the segregated steady state (i.e., bronze or glass layer on top) is a sensitive function of gas pressure and viscosity, as well as vibration frequency and amplitude. In particular, we identify distinct regimes of behavior that characterize the change from bronze-on-top to glass-on-top steady-state.

Soft Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the **influence of interstitial gas on mass - density sorting in vertically vibrating granular media**. Specifically, the author experimentally explored whether the vertically vibrating mixed particles (consisting of bronze and glass balls) would stratify according to their density in the presence of interstitial gas, and how this stratification phenomenon depends on factors such as gas pressure, viscosity, and vibration frequency and amplitude.

### Research Background and Problem Description

1. **Characteristics of Granular Media**
Granular media exhibit properties similar to solids, liquids, or gases under vertical vibration, but are also different. There are still many unsolved problems regarding the application of hydrodynamic theories to these systems and the formation of their patterns and ordered structures.

2. **Role of Interstitial Gas**
Previous studies have shown that interstitial gas (rather than vacuum) is a key factor in achieving mass - density stratification of particles. For example, in a binary - particle system, particles of the same size can undergo significant vertical stratification during vertical vibration due to the presence of interstitial gas.

3. **Experimental Objectives**
This study aims to explore in detail the influence of interstitial gas (such as nitrogen \(N_2\) and neon \(Ne\)) on the particle stratification behavior. Specifically, the author hopes to understand:
- The influence of different gas pressures and viscosities on the stratification behavior.
- The influence of vibration frequency and amplitude on the stratification results.
- The mobility of particles and the bed expansion during the stratification process.

### Experimental Methods

- **Experimental Apparatus**
A sealed rectangular borosilicate glass sample cell containing a mixture of bronze and glass balls of equal size was used. The sample cell was installed on an electromagnetic vibration platform, and the vibration conditions were controlled by changing the vibration frequency \(f\) and the dimensionless acceleration \(\Gamma=\frac{A\omega^{2}}{g}\).

- **Gas Control**
The type and pressure (\(P = 1 - 1000\) Torr) of the interstitial gas in the sample cell were controlled through a gas delivery system, and the influence of gas viscosity \(\eta\) on the stratification behavior was monitored.

### Main Findings

1. **Dependence of Stratification Behavior**
- At low gas pressures (about 200 Torr or lower), a stable state with glass balls on top will not occur.
- As the gas pressure increases, glass balls are more likely to be dragged to the top, forming a "glass - on - top" stratification.
- At higher gas pressures and lower vibration frequencies, an "overflow" mechanism was observed, causing the glass balls to break through the bronze layer and form a stable "glass - on - top" stratification.

2. **Critical Parameter \(\Gamma_{c}\)**
- A critical dimensionless acceleration \(\Gamma_{c}\) was defined to distinguish the transition point from "bronze - on - top" to "glass - on - top".
- It was found that the value of \(\Gamma_{c}\) varies with gas pressure, vibration frequency, and gas viscosity, especially showing significant differences at different frequencies.

3. **Four Typical Behavior Regions**
- **Region I**: No "glass - on - top" stratification occurs at low gas pressures.
- **Region II**: At medium gas pressures and high vibration frequencies, stratification occurs when the sample surface is basically flat.
- **Region III**: At high gas pressures, "glass - on - top" stratification is achieved through the "overflow" mechanism.
- **Region IV**: At low vibration frequencies and high gas pressures, the stratification behavior depends on gas pressure.

### Conclusion

This paper reveals the importance of interstitial gas in vertically vibrating granular media, especially in controlling and influencing particle stratification behavior. The research results not only help to understand the dynamic characteristics of granular media, but also provide a theoretical basis for optimizing particle sorting in future industrial applications.