Modeling Accelerated Pick-up Ion Distributions at an Interplanetary Shock

Errol J. Summerlin,Matthew G. Baring
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asr.2005.05.116
2005-05-28
Abstract:The acceleration of interstellar pick-up ions as well as solar wind species has been observed at a multitude of interplanetary (IP) shocks by different spacecraft. The efficiency of injection of the pick-up ion component differs from that of the solar wind, and is expected to be strongly enhanced at highly oblique and quasi-perpendicular shock events, in accord with inferences from {\it in situ} observations. This paper explores theoretical modeling of the phase space distributions of accelerated ions obtained by the Ulysses mission for the Day 292, 1991 shock associated with a corotating interaction region, encountered before Ulysses' fly-by of Jupiter. A Monte Carlo simulation is used to model the acceleration process, adapting a technique that has been successfully tested on earlier IP shocks possessing minimal pick-up ion presence. Phase space distributions from the simulation technique for various low mass ions are compared with SWICS and HI-SCALE data to deduce values of a ``turbulence parameter'' that controls the efficiency of injection, and the degree of cross-field diffusion. Acceptable fits are obtained for the $H^+$ and $He^+$ populations using standard prescriptions for the pick-up ion distribution; $He^{++}$ spectral data was only fit well for scenarios very close to the Bohm diffusion limit. It is also found that the simulation successfully accounts for the observation of energetic protons farther upstream of the forward shock than lower energy pick-up protons, using the same turbulence parameter that is required to achieve reasonable spectral fits.
Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: to understand and simulate the acceleration process of interstellar pick - up ions in the interplanetary shock, especially the corotating interaction region (CIR) shock event observed by the Ulysses mission on October 29, 1991 (Day 292, 1991). Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Interpret observational data**: Through theoretical modeling and Monte Carlo simulations, interpret the accelerated ion phase - space distributions observed by the SWICS and HI - SCALE instruments in the Ulysses mission. 2. **Determine turbulence parameters**: Find a suitable "turbulence parameter" \(\eta\), which controls the injection efficiency and the degree of cross - field diffusion and can better fit the observational data. 3. **Verify the acceleration mechanism**: Verify the effectiveness of the diffusive shock acceleration (DSA) model in explaining the acceleration of high - energy protons and helium ions, especially under highly oblique shock conditions. 4. **Explore the behavioral differences of different ions**: Study the differences in the acceleration behaviors of hydrogen ions (H⁺) and helium ions (He⁺, He²⁺) in the shock and the impact of these differences on the overall acceleration process. ### Main problems and methods - **Problem background**: Interstellar pick - up ions are low - energy ions formed after the ionization of neutral particles in the solar wind and can be accelerated to higher energies in the interplanetary shock. This acceleration process is crucial for understanding the interaction between the solar wind and the interstellar medium. - **Research methods**: - Use Monte Carlo simulation techniques to simulate the diffusive shock acceleration process. - Adjust the turbulence parameter \(\eta\) so that the simulation results match the observational data. - Compare the acceleration efficiencies and phase - space distributions of different ions (such as H⁺, He⁺, He²⁺). ### Key findings - **Turbulence parameter \(\eta\)**: By adjusting \(\eta\), the researchers found that \(\eta = 5.5\) can better fit the observational data of H⁺ and He⁺, but when fitting He²⁺, it needs to be close to the Bohm diffusion limit (\(\eta\sim1\)). - **High - energy protons and helium ions**: The simulation results show that the acceleration behaviors of high - energy protons and He⁺ are in good agreement with the observational data, while there are some deviations in the high - speed part of thermal protons. - **The importance of cross - field diffusion**: Cross - field diffusion plays an important role in explaining the acceleration process of He²⁺, especially under highly oblique shock conditions. In conclusion, through detailed theoretical modeling and simulation, this paper successfully explains the ion acceleration phenomenon in the shock event on October 29, 1991 observed by the Ulysses mission and provides an important reference for future research.