Abstract:Binary decision-making process is ubiquitous in social life and is of vital significance in many real-world issues, ranging from public health to political campaigns. While continuous opinion evolution independent of discrete choice behavior has been extensively studied, few works unveil how the group binary decision-making result is determined by the coupled dynamics of these two processes. To this end, we propose an agent-based model to study the collective behaviors of individual binary decision-making process through competitive opinion dynamics on social networks. Three key factors are considered: bounded confidence that describes the cognitive scope of the population, stubbornness level that characterizes the opinion updating speed, and the opinion strength that represents the asymmetry power or attractiveness of the two choices. We find that bounded confidence plays an important role in determining competing evolution results. As bounded confidence grows, population opinions experience polarization to consensus, leading to the emergence of phase transition from co-existence to winner-takes-all state under binary decisions. Of particular interest, we show how the combined effects of bounded confidence and asymmetry opinion strength may reverse the initial supportive advantage in competitive dynamics. Notably, our model qualitatively reproduces the important dynamical pattern during a brutal competition, namely, cascading collapse, as observed by real data. Finally and intriguingly, we find that individual cognitive heterogeneity can bring about randomness and unpredictability in binary decision-making process, leading to the emergence of indeterministic oscillation. Our results reveal how the diverse behavioral patterns of binary decision-making can be interpreted by the complicated interactions of the proposed elements, which provides important insights toward competitive dynamics

Emergence of two-phase behavior in markets through interaction and learning in agents with bounded rationality

Self-organization and phase transition in financial markets with multiple choices

Phase transition and cascading collapse in binary decision-making dynamics

Bounded strategic reasoning explains crisis emergence in multi-agent market games

Partial Information, Market Efficiency, and Anomalous Continuous Phase Transition

Chaotic-periodic Transition in a Two-Sided Minority Game

Direct limits of infinite-dimensional Lie groups compared to direct limits in related categories

Understanding agent-based models of financial markets: a bottom-up approach based on order parameters and phase diagrams

Islands for SAT

Rational Expectations, psychology and inductive learning via moving thresholds

Human behavioral regularity, fractional Brownian motion, and exotic phase transition

Multi-agent Economics and the Emergence of Critical Markets

Phase separation and scaling in correlation structures of financial markets

Emergence of chaos in interacting communities

Theory of Phase Transition in the Evolutionary Minority Game

Comment on: "Two-phase behaviour of financial markets"

Elements of decisional dynamics: An agent-based approach applied to artificial financial market

Emergence of universal scaling in financial markets from mean-field dynamics

Emergence of information aggregation to rational expectations equilibria in markets populated by biased heuristic traders

Non-Normal Interactions Create Socio-Economic Bubbles