The Uses of Argument in Mathematics

Andrew Aberdein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10503-005-4417-8

2005-04-07

Abstract:Stephen Toulmin once observed that `it has never been customary for philosophers to pay much attention to the rhetoric of mathematical debate'. Might the application of Toulmin's layout of arguments to mathematics remedy this oversight? Toulmin's critics fault the layout as requiring so much abstraction as to permit incompatible reconstructions. Mathematical proofs may indeed be represented by fundamentally distinct layouts. However, cases of genuine conflict characteristically reflect an underlying disagreement about the nature of the proof in question.

History and Overview

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve several key problems in cosmology, especially the challenges related to dark energy and cosmic inflation. Specifically, the author proposes a new method named "Slinky Inflation", aiming to simultaneously explain the phenomena of dark energy and cosmic inflation through the evolution of a single scalar field. The following are the main objectives of this paper:

1. **Unify dark energy and cosmic inflation**:
- The author hopes to use the same scalar field to explain dark energy and cosmic inflation by introducing a simple scalar potential with oscillatory and exponential behaviors. This can avoid the complexity of having to deal with these two problems separately in traditional models.

2. **Solve the "Why now?" problem**:
- The "Why now?" problem is about why we are exactly in a dark - energy - dominated era at present. The method proposed by the author utilizes the tracking and oscillatory characteristics of the scalar field, making the scalar field exhibit the behavior of accelerated expansion in some periods, thus naturally explaining the currently observed dark - energy - dominated phenomenon.

3. **Meet the constraints of cosmological observations**:
- This model needs to be able to explain observational data such as the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB), large - scale structures, and nucleosynthesis. The author shows that their model can automatically meet these observational constraints without additional parameter adjustments.

4. **Achieve sufficient reheating**:
- In the new cosmic inflation model, the reheating mechanism is an important part. The author adopts a standard new - inflation reheating mechanism, in which the scalar field decays into light fermions, and the decay width is proportional to the scalar mass. Since the scalar mass is proportional to the Hubble rate, this makes the model have sufficient reheating effects in the early stage and naturally closes in the late stage to maintain one - fifth of the energy and meet the nucleosynthesis constraints.

5. **Predict the cosmic inflation spectral index**:
- The author calculates the scalar and tensor perturbations during inflation and predicts the inflation spectral indices \(n_S\) and \(n_T\). The results show that \(n_S = n_T = 1\), which is consistent with the predictions of the standard cosmological model.

In summary, the core objective of this paper is to simultaneously explain the phenomena of dark energy and cosmic inflation by introducing a new scalar field model and ensure that this model can meet the existing cosmological observational data.