Magnetic Susceptibility as a Macrosopic Entaglement Witness

M. Wiesniak,V. Vedral,C. Brukner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/7/1/258

2006-02-13

Abstract:We show that magnetic susceptibility can reveal spin entanglement between individual constituents of a solid, while magnetisation describes their local properties. We then show that these two thermodynamical quantities satisfy complementary relation in the quantum-mechanical sense. It describes sharing of (quantum) information in the solid between spin entanglement and local properties of its individual constituents. Magnetic susceptibility is shown to be a macroscopic spin entanglement witness that can be applied without complete knowledge of the specific model (Hamiltonian) of the solid.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to reveal the existence of spin - quantum entanglement in solids through macroscopic thermodynamic properties (such as magnetic susceptibility)**. Specifically, the author explored the following issues:

1. **Manifestation of quantum characteristics on the macroscopic scale**: Normally, quantum characteristics such as superposition states and entangled states are only visible on the molecular scale. As the mass and complexity of the system increase, these quantum effects will gradually be limited by the decoherence effect and turn into classical phenomena. Therefore, the author raises the question: Under what conditions can the quantum characteristics of individual components in solids affect their overall properties?

2. **Detecting quantum entanglement through thermodynamic properties**: Can the existence of quantum entanglement in a solid be detected only by observing its thermodynamic properties (such as magnetic susceptibility)? In other words, can macroscopic properties be regarded as quantum - mechanical observables, thus following a complementary relationship similar to that between position and momentum?

3. **Magnetic susceptibility as a macroscopic entanglement witness**: The author further explored whether magnetic susceptibility can be used as a macroscopic entanglement witness (entanglement witness), that is, an observable that can reveal the existence of quantum entanglement without fully understanding the Hamiltonian of the system.

### Main contributions of the paper

The main contribution of the paper lies in proving the effectiveness of **the sum of magnetic susceptibility in three orthogonal directions** (\(\chi_x+\chi_y +\chi_z\)) as a macroscopic entanglement witness. Specifically, the author showed that when this sum is less than a certain critical value, there is spin entanglement in the solid system. The significance of this finding is as follows:

- **Experimental feasibility**: The measurement of magnetic susceptibility is already a common experimental method, so this method has high experimental feasibility.
- **No need to fully understand the system model**: Unlike other methods such as internal energy, magnetic susceptibility as an entanglement witness does not require a full understanding of the specific Hamiltonian of the system and is applicable to a wider range of materials.
- **Revealing multi - body entanglement**: Magnetic susceptibility can detect not only two - body entanglement between adjacent spins but also multi - body entanglement between non - adjacent spins.

### Summary of mathematical formulas

The key formulas involved in the paper include:

1. **Expression of magnetic susceptibility**:
\[
\chi_z=\frac{1}{kT}(\langle M_z^2\rangle-\langle M_z\rangle^2)=\frac{1}{kT}\left(\sum_{i,j = 1}^N\langle s_i^z s_j^z\rangle-\left(\sum_{i = 1}^N\langle s_i^z\rangle\right)^2\right)
\]

2. **Entanglement witness condition**:
\[
\bar{\chi}\equiv\chi_x+\chi_y+\chi_z\geq\frac{Ns}{kT}
\]
If \(\chi_x+\chi_y+\chi_z<\frac{Ns}{kT}\), then there is entanglement in the system.

3. **Macroscopic quantum complementary relationship**:
\[
1-\frac{kT\bar{\chi}}{Ns}+\frac{\langle\vec{M}\rangle^2}{N^2s^2}\leq1
\]

These formulas reveal the complementary relationship between magnetic susceptibility and magnetization intensity and describe the sharing of quantum information between local and non - local properties.