Use of time-correlated single photon counting detection to measure the speed of light in water

Pedro L. Muino,Aaron M. Thompson,Robert J. Buenker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0502100

2005-02-18

Abstract:Traditional methods for measuring the speed of light in dispersive media have been based on the detection of interference between light waves emitted from the same source. In the present study the elapsed times for single photons to move from a laser to a photomultiplier tube are measured electronically. Time-correlated single photon counting detection produces a characteristic instrument response which has the same shape independent of both the path length the light travels and the nature of the transparent media through which it passes. This allows for an accurate calibration of the chronograph by observing shifts in the location of the instrument response for different distances traveled by the light. Measurement of the corresponding shift which occurs when light moves the same distance through air and water then enables an accurate determination of the ratio of the photon velocities in these two media. Three different wavelengths of light have been used. In two cases good agreement is found between the present measured light speeds and those which can be inferred from existing refractive index measurements in water. The shortest wavelength studied is too far in the uv to obtain a reliable estimate on the same basis, and so the ng value (1.463) measured in the present work awaits independent confirmation. A theoretical discussion of the present results is undertaken with reference to Newton's original corpuscular theory of light. It is argued that his failure to predict that light travels more slowly in water than in air arose from the inadequacy of his mechanical theory rather than his assumptions about the elementary composition of light.

Classical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to measure the speed of light propagation in water and verify whether the speed of a single photon can be accurately measured by the Time - Correlated Single Photon Counting (TCSPC) method. Traditional methods usually rely on the interference phenomenon between light waves from the same light source to measure the speed of light, while this paper proposes a new method to measure the time it takes for a single photon to travel from a laser source to a Photomultiplier Tube (PMT) by electronic means.

Specifically, the paper aims to:

1. **Verify the effectiveness of the TCSPC method**: By measuring the time difference required for photons to travel the same distance in air and water, calibrate the instrument response, and thus determine the speed of light propagation in different media.
2. **Compare the speed of light at different wavelengths**: The speed of light at three different wavelengths (810 nm, 405 nm, and 270 nm) in air and water was studied and compared with the existing refractive index data.
3. **Explore the limitations of Newton's particle theory**: Analyze why Newton's particle theory failed to correctly predict that the speed of light in water is slower than that in air.

### Main Conclusions

- For light with wavelengths of 810 nm and 405 nm, the experimentally measured speed of light is consistent with the results calculated based on the refractive index.
- For light with a wavelength of 270 nm, since it is in the ultraviolet region, it is difficult to obtain reliable refractive index data, but the experimentally measured ratio of the speed of light is 1.463, and this result needs further confirmation.
- The experimental results show that the speed of a single photon can be accurately measured by the TCSPC method, and the speed of light propagation in water is indeed slower than that in air, which is consistent with the prediction of the wave theory and inconsistent with Newton's particle theory.

### Formula Summary

- **Group refractive index formula**:
\[
n_g(\omega) = n(\omega) + \omega \frac{d}{d\omega} n(\omega)
\]
- **Uncertainty principle**:
\[
\Delta E \Delta t \geq h
\]

These results not only verify the feasibility of the TCSPC method but also provide experimental evidence for further understanding the nature of light.