Quantum theory of spectral diffusion induced electron spin decoherence

W. M. Witzel,Rogerio de Sousa,S. Das Sarma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.72.161306

2005-10-28

Abstract:A quantum cluster expansion method is developed for the problem of localized electron spin decoherence due to dipolar fluctuations of lattice nuclear spins. At the lowest order it provides a microscopic explanation for the Lorentzian diffusion of Hahn echoes without resorting to any phenomenological Markovian assumption. Our numerical results show remarkable agreement with recent electron spin echo experiments in phosphorus doped silicon.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **the spectral diffusion problem caused by dipole fluctuations of lattice nuclear spins in local electron - spin decoherence (decoherence)**. Specifically, the author aims to develop a quantum - theoretical framework to explain and predict the electron - spin echo decay phenomenon in phosphorus - doped silicon without relying on any empirical Markov assumptions or classical stochastic models.

### Problem Background
In electron - spin echo experiments, spectral diffusion caused by dipole fluctuations of nuclear spins often dominates the decay of spin coherence. In recent years, research on spin - based quantum computing in semiconductor nanostructures has reignited interest in spectral diffusion because this effect is expected to be the main channel for spin decoherence at low temperatures. Traditional theories are usually based on classical stochastic models and Markov assumptions, and these methods have certain limitations, especially in quantum - information devices that strictly require spin coherence and control.

### Core Contributions of the Paper
1. **Quantum - Theoretical Framework**: The author proposes a brand - new quantum - theoretical framework for describing spectral diffusion caused by dipole - coupled nuclear spins. This framework is non - stochastic and fully microscopic and can provide accurate quantitative predictions of initial decoherence, which is especially important for quantum computing.

2. **Natural Explanation of Hahn Echo Decay**: Through the collective quantum - evolution mechanism, the author's method naturally explains the time - dependence of Hahn echo decay without introducing any empirical assumptions about environmental dynamics. In particular, it can well fit the \( \exp(-\tau^2) \) time - dependence observed in experimental data.

3. **Correcting the Deficiencies of Existing Theories**: The author points out that there is approximately a three - fold difference between existing Markov stochastic theories and experimental data. Their quantum theory explains this difference by considering quantum corrections of nuclear - spin fluctuations.

4. **Applicability to Different Material Systems**: Although spectral diffusion is not a limiting decoherence process in silicon - and germanium - based quantum - computer proposals (nuclear spins can be removed by isotope purification), in III - V compound materials, spectral diffusion plays an important role. Therefore, this theory provides an important tool for studying spin coherence in these materials.

### Summary of Mathematical Formulas
- **Hamiltonian**:
\[
H = H_{Ze} + H_{Zn} + H_A + H_B
\]
where,
\[
H_{Ze} = \gamma_S B S_z, \quad H_{Zn} = -\gamma_I B \sum_n I_{nz}, \quad H_A = \sum_n A_n I_{nz} S_z, \quad H_B = \sum_{n \neq m} b_{nm} (I_n^+ I_m^- - 2 I_{nz} I_{mz})
\]

- **Density - Matrix Evolution**:
\[
\rho(\tau) = U(\tau) \rho_0 U^\dagger(\tau), \quad U(\tau) = e^{-iH\tau} \sigma_x e^{-iH\tau}
\]

- **Echo - Envelope Function**:
\[
v_E(\tau) = \frac{1}{M} \left| \text{Tr}\left\{ U_+ U_- e^{-H_n / k_B T} U_+^\dagger U_-^\dagger \right\} \right|
\]

- **τ - Expansion**:
\[
v_E(\tau) = 1 - \sum_{l = 1}^\infty D_{2l} \tau^{2l}
\]

- **Cluster - Expansion**:
\[
v_E(\tau) = \prod_{n < m} \left[ 1 + v'_{nm}(\tau) [1 + O(\lambda L)] \right] + O\left( \frac{(\lambda^2 N L)^{l_0}}{l_0!} \right)
\]