Revisiting the driving force inducing phase separation in PEG-phosphate aqueous biphasic systems

Sophie Bonnassieux,Raj Pandya,Dhyllan Adan Skiba,Damien Degoulange,Dorothee Petit,Peter Seem,Russell Cowburn,Betar M Gallant,Alexis Jules Louis Grimaud

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4fd00058g

2024-04-25

Faraday Discussions

Abstract:Liquid phase separation using aqueous biphasic systems (ABS) is widely used in industrial processes for the extraction, separation and purification of macromolecules. Using water as the single solvent, a wide variety of solutes have been used to induce phase separation including polymers, ionic liquids or salts. For each system - polymer-polymer, polymer-ionic liquid, polymer-salt or salt-salt - different driving forces were proposed to induce phase separation. Specifically, for polymer-salt systems, a difference in solvation structure between the polymer-rich and the salt-rich was proposed, while other reports suggested that a large change in enthalpy and entropy accompanied the phase separation. Here, we reinvestigated the PEG/K2HPO4/H2O systems using a combination of liquid-phase nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and high-resolution Raman spectroscopies, coupled with injection microcalorimetry. Both NMR and Raman reveal a decreased water concentration in the PEG-rich phase, with nonetheless no significant differences observed for both 1H chemical shift or OH stretching vibrations. Hence, both PEG- and salt-rich phases exhibit similar water solvation properties, which is thus not the driving force for phase separation. Furthermore, NMR reveals a that PEG interacts with salt ions in the PEG-rich solution, inducing a downfield shift with increasing salt concentration. Injection microcalorimetry measurements were carried out to investigate any effect due to enthalpy change during mixing. Nevertheless, these measurements indicate very small enthalpy changes when mixing PEG- and salt-rich solutions in comparison with that previously recorded for salt-salt systems or associated with mixing of two solvents. Hence, our study discards any large change of enthalpy as the origin for phase separation of PEG/K2HPO4 systems, in addition to large difference in solvation properties.

chemistry, physical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the nature of the driving force for phase separation in the Aqueous Biphasic Systems (ABS) of polyethylene glycol (PEG) and potassium phosphate (K₂HPO₄). Specifically, the authors re - examined the phase separation mechanism of the PEG/K₂HPO₄/H₂O system and explored whether the changes in solvation properties and the enthalpy change of mixing are the main driving forces for phase separation by combining techniques such as liquid - phase nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), high - resolution Raman spectroscopy, and injection microcalorimetry.

### Main research questions:
1. **Differences in solvation structures**: Is it the significant differences in the solvation structures of water molecules between the PEG - rich phase and the salt - rich phase that drive the phase separation?
2. **Enthalpy and entropy changes**: Are there significant enthalpy and entropy changes during the phase separation process, and are these changes the main driving forces for phase separation?

### Research background:
- Aqueous Biphasic Systems (ABS) are widely used in industrial processes, especially in the extraction, separation, and purification of biomolecules.
- Traditional explanations suggest that phase separation may be caused by differences in solvation structures between different phases or driven by enthalpy and entropy changes during the mixing process.
- The authors re - evaluated these hypotheses through multiple experimental techniques and reached new conclusions.

### Experimental methods:
- **Phase diagram construction**: Use cloud - point titration to measure the phase diagrams at different PEG chain lengths and salt concentrations.
- **NMR spectroscopy**: Analyze the species concentrations and their interactions in the two phases by 1H and ³¹P NMR spectroscopy.
- **Raman spectroscopy**: Analyze the solvation structures of water molecules by Raman spectroscopy.
- **Microcalorimetry**: Measure the enthalpy change during the mixing process by injection microcalorimetry.

### Conclusions:
- **Solvation structures**: The results of NMR and Raman spectroscopy show that the water solvation properties between the PEG - rich phase and the salt - rich phase are similar and there are no significant differences. Therefore, the difference in solvation structures is not the main driving force for phase separation.
- **Enthalpy change**: The results of microcalorimetry measurements show that the enthalpy change during the mixing process is very small, much smaller than that in previously reported salt - salt systems. Therefore, the enthalpy change is also not the main driving force for phase separation.

In summary, through detailed experimental data and analysis, this paper negates the hypotheses that the differences in solvation structures and the enthalpy change are the main driving forces for phase separation in the PEG/K₂HPO₄ system. This finding is of great significance for understanding the phase separation mechanism of Aqueous Biphasic Systems.