The more, the better? Learning with feedback and instruction

Salome Wagner,Leonie Sibley,David Weiler,Jan-Philipp Burde,Katharina Scheiter,Andreas Lachner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2023.101844

IF: 6.636

2023-10-29

Learning and Instruction

Abstract:Background Strategy instruction and formative feedback are powerful instructional strategies to support learning. However, combining them may not necessarily be effective. Previous research on the combination of strategy instruction and feedback produced both additive and reducing effects on learning. It is an open question whether and under which conditions combining strategy instruction and feedback enhances students' learning. Aims We investigated potential synergy and interaction effects of combining strategy instruction and feedback on learning in physics, the underlying mechanisms, and their generalizability (elaboration level of feedback, instructional sequence). Sample We conducted three online experiments ( N 1 = 437, N 2 = 310, N 3 = 166) with university students. Method In Experiment 1 and 2, in the learning phase, participants read a strategy instruction or no instruction. In a subsequent practice phase, they solved troubleshooting tasks on electric circuits and received either feedback or no feedback. In Experiment 3, students were randomly assigned to one of three conditions (no intervention, learning phase first, practice phase first). We used the same material for all experiments. Results In Experiment 1, we found no additive combination effects of strategy instruction and corrective feedback. Surprisingly, for far transfer, corrective feedback reduced the effect of prior instruction. Contrarily, in Experiment 2, we obtained additive effects by combining strategy instruction with elaborated feedback. Experiment 3 showed that these additive findings were irrespective of the instruction-feedback-sequence. Conclusions Our findings indicate that the elaboration level of feedback determines whether combining instruction and feedback produces additive or reducing effects.

education & educational research,psychology, educational