Distributions of vanadyl and nickel porphyrins in the Woodford Shale and selective chelation of metal species by different tetrapyrrole configurations

Derek R. Parks,Xiao-Lei Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orggeochem.2023.104693
IF: 3.623
2023-11-09
Organic Geochemistry
Abstract:Abundant vanadyl (VO) and nickel (Ni) porphyrins were detected in the Late Devonian–Early Mississippian Woodford formation shales using a recently developed reverse-phase liquid chromatography quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry with electrospray ionization (RPLC-ESI-qTOF-MS) method. This Woodford shale sequence is characterized by the presence of sustained photic zone euxinia (PZE), as indicated by the occurrence of green sulfur bacteria-produced isorenieratane. The distribution of VO- and Ni-porphyrins, expressed as the VO/(VO + Ni) ratio, reflects a generally reducing/sulfidic condition throughout most of the Woodford deposition. However, in the later Upper Woodford, there is a significant drop in the VO/(VO + Ni) ratio, marking the collapse of anoxia/euxinia due to gradual oxygenation. The depth profiles of VO- and Ni-porphyrin concentrations exhibit a remarkable increase during the peak of PZE in the Middle Woodford, implying that Ni-porphyrin is not completely limited by sulfide. All three categories of porphyrin structures, namely bicycloalkanoporphyrin (BiCAP), deoxophylloerythroethioporphyrin (DPEP), and etioporphyrin (Etio), occurred in VO- and Ni-porphyrins. VO 2+ exhibits a preferential chelation to BiCAP over the other two types of porphyrins. In contrast, Ni-porphyrins are predominantly composed of Etio structures. Due to such selective binding of metal species to specific porphyrin structures, the relative abundance of VO- and Ni-porphyrins (VO/Ni) exhibits a strong positive correlation ( R 2 > 0.83) with the ratio of BiCAP to Etio (BiCAP/Etio). These findings suggest that the distribution of VO- and Ni-porphyrins in sediments is not solely controlled by the availability of metal ions. When both VO 2+ and Ni 2+ are not limited, the molecular configurations of porphyrins determine the relative abundance of VO- and Ni-porphyrins. Further investigations into the influence of biological and diagenetic processes on the production of BiCAP and Etio are crucial and warrant future research endeavors.
geochemistry & geophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?