An improved estimate of black hole entropy in the quantum geometry approach

A. Ghosh,P. Mitra

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2005.05.003

2005-05-30

Abstract: A proper counting of states for black holes in the quantum geometry approach shows that the dominant configuration for spins are distributions that include spins exceeding one-half at the punctures. This raises the value of the Immirzi parameter and the black hole entropy. However, the coefficient of the logarithmic correction remains -1/2 as before.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: to estimate black - hole entropy more accurately within the framework of loop quantum gravity. Specifically, the authors recalculate the black - hole entropy by allowing higher spin values (not just 1/2) and explore the impact of this change on the Immirzi parameter and the leading term and logarithmic correction term of the entropy.

### Main problems and background

1. **Quantum geometric method**:
- The quantum geometric method is a theoretical framework for studying quantum gravity.
- In this framework, the calculation of black - hole entropy depends on counting the quantum states on the isolated horizon.

2. **Previous research**:
- Early work assumed that each puncture carried only spin 1/2, which led to a lower entropy estimate.
- Subsequent research found that considering higher spin values can increase the entropy estimate, but the logarithmic correction term ($-\frac{1}{2}\ln A$) remains unchanged.

3. **Improvements in this paper**:
- The authors allow all non - zero spin values and consider the spin $j$ and its projection $m$ as relevant quantum numbers.
- This new treatment enables them to estimate black - hole entropy more accurately and further adjust the Immirzi parameter.

### Specific problems

- **Leading term of entropy**: By allowing higher spin values, the authors hope to find a larger leading term, thereby describing black - hole entropy more accurately.
- **Logarithmic correction term**: Despite the introduction of higher spin values, does the logarithmic correction term still remain $-\frac{1}{2}\ln A$?
- **Immirzi parameter**: How to adjust the Immirzi parameter according to the new entropy estimate?

### Conclusion

By allowing higher spin values and considering the spin projection $m$, the authors obtain a new entropy estimation formula:

\[ S=\lambda\frac{A}{2}-\frac{(\ln A)^3}{3\lambda^2} \]

where $A$ is the horizon area and $\lambda\approx1.72$. Eventually, they find that the logarithmic correction term is still $-\frac{1}{2}\ln A$, while the leading term has increased.

Overall, this paper provides a more accurate black - hole entropy estimate by improving the spin - distribution assumption in the quantum geometric method and discusses the impact of this improvement on the Immirzi parameter.