A. A. Deriglazov,B. F. Rizzuti
Abstract: We present and discuss two different possibilities to construct position space version for Magueijo-Smolin (MS) doubly special relativity proposal. The first possibility is to start from ordinary special relativity and then to define conserved momentum in special way. It generates MS invariant as well as nonlinear MS transformations on the momentum space, leading to consistent picture for one-particle sector of the theory. The second possibility is based on the following observation. Besides the nonlinear MS transformations, the MS energy-momentum relation is invariant also under some inhomogeneous linear transformations. The latter are induced starting from linearly realized Lorentz group in five-dimensional position space. Particle dynamics and kinematics are formulated starting from the corresponding five-dimensional interval. There is no problem of total momentum in the theory. The formulation admits two observer independent scales, the speed of light, $c$, and $k$ with dimension of velocity. We speculate on different possibilities to relate $k$ with fundamental constants. In particular, expression of $k$ in terms of vacuum energy suggests emergence of (minimum) quantum of mass.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the momentum composition in Doubly Special Relativity (DSR), especially the definition and consistency of the total momentum in the Magueijo - Smolin (MS) proposal. Specifically:
1. **Total Momentum Problem**:
- In traditional special relativity, the total momentum of a multi - particle system is the simple addition of the momenta of individual particles, and this total momentum remains covariant under Lorentz transformation.
- However, in the MS DSR framework, due to the non - linear transformation of momentum space, the ordinary momentum addition rule no longer applies, resulting in a complex and inconsistent definition of the total momentum in multi - particle systems. This is known as the "soccer ball problem", that is, for macroscopic objects (such as a soccer ball), how to handle the momentum composition of a large number of its internal microscopic particles.
2. **Construction of the Position - Space Version**:
- To overcome the above problems, the author proposes two different methods to construct the position - space version of MS DSR to ensure the consistency of the theory and the clarity of its physical meaning.
### First Method: Starting from Special Relativity
- **Idea**: Starting from classical special relativity, re - define the conserved momentum in an appropriate way so that it satisfies the invariance and non - linear transformation characteristics of MS DSR.
- **Result**: This method can well describe the behavior of single - particle systems, but in multi - particle systems, it still faces the problem of defining the total momentum.
### Second Method: Linear Realization in Five - Dimensional Spacetime
- **Idea**: Keep the traditional definition of conserved momentum, but introduce five - dimensional spacetime (\(M^4\times\mathbb{R}\)) to deform the realization of the Lorentz group, thereby naturally deriving the MS - type energy - momentum relation.
- **Result**: This method avoids the total momentum problem and introduces a new independent observer scale \(k\) in five - dimensional spacetime, making the theory more self - consistent.
### Summary
The main purpose of the paper is to solve the total momentum problem existing in MS DSR and proposes two methods for constructing the position - space version. The first method is suitable for single - particle systems but has limitations for multi - particle systems; the second method successfully solves the total momentum problem by introducing five - dimensional spacetime and provides a broader theoretical framework.
In addition, the paper also discusses how to relate the newly introduced scale \(k\) to fundamental constants (such as the speed of light \(c\), Planck's constant \(\hbar\), and the cosmological constant \(\Lambda\)) to further explore the physical meaning and possible applications of the DSR theory.