Variation of debris flow/flood formation conditions at the watershed scale in the Wenchuan Earthquake area

Xiaojun Guo,Yong Li,Xingchang Chen,Ju Zhang,Yuqing Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10346-021-01644-2

IF: 6.153

2021-03-03

Landslides

Abstract:A channelized debris flow/flood generally originates from initial gully erosion by superficial runoff that evolves rapidly into massive erosion of the channel bed. Knowledge of the formation conditions of such events is crucial for accurate forecasting, and determination of rainfall and runoff thresholds for such hazards is a primary concern following a strong earthquake. This work proposed a framework for debris flow/flood formation at the watershed scale in two watersheds (area: 2.4 and 32.4 km²) in the Wenchuan Earthquake area (China). The critical runoff and rainfall conditions required for debris flow/flood formation were simulated and their annual variations investigated. Ultimately, the runoff conditions required for debris flow/flood formation in the two studied watersheds were calculated on an annual basis and found to increase in time. Similarly, following consideration of three different rainfall types, critical rainfall conditions were proposed that also showed an increasing tendency. The increase of rainfall and runoff conditions for debris flow/flood formation is attributable to both the recovery of vegetation and the reduction of source materials. In comparison with actual monitored flow behaviors and previously proposed rainfall thresholds, the results showed strong consistency and high forecasting efficiency.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,engineering, geological

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: the changes in the formation conditions of debris flows/floods on the watershed scale in the Wenchuan earthquake - stricken area. Specifically, the study focused on the critical runoff and rainfall conditions for the formation of debris flows/floods in two watersheds (with areas of 2.4 and 32.4 square kilometers respectively), and explored the changing trends of these conditions over time. The study verified these changes through simulation and monitoring data, and found that as vegetation restoration and the reduction of source materials, the required critical runoff and rainfall conditions gradually increased. This provides an important reference basis for debris flow/flood prediction in this area.

### Research Background and Problems
- **Hazards of Debris Flows/Floods**: Debris flows/floods are common geological disasters, especially in mountainous areas such as the Wenchuan earthquake area. Such disasters may lead to casualties, infrastructure destruction, and hindrance to social and economic development.
- **Importance of Prediction**: Accurate prediction of the occurrence time and scale of debris flows/floods is crucial for reducing economic losses and social impacts.
- **Triggering Factors**: Debris flows/floods are usually triggered by rapid surface runoff caused by sudden rainstorms, and the loose materials accumulated after the earthquake provide a rich source of materials for debris flows/floods.

### Research Methods
- **Framework**: The study proposed a framework that combines hydrological simulation and an empirical - based debris flow/flood initiation model to evaluate the critical formation conditions in the rainfall - runoff - debris flow/flood process.
- **Data Sources**: Historical rainfall and flow monitoring data were used, including data from rain gauges and hydrological stations.
- **Model Application**: Two empirical formulas were used to calculate the critical runoff conditions:
- **Formula by Tognacca et al. (2000)**:
\[
q_c = 4.0 D_m^{1.5} \tan(\theta)^{1.17}
\]
where \(\theta\) is the average slope angle of the riverbed, and \(D_m\) is the median particle diameter (in meters).
- **Formula by Zhuang (2011)**:
\[
Q = \begin{cases}
40 d g^{0.5} D_m^{1.5} \tan(\theta)^{0.1} & \text{if } 10^\circ \leq \theta \leq 14^\circ \\
2.4 d g^{0.5} D_m^{1.5} \tan(\theta)^{2.1} & \text{if } 14^\circ \leq \theta \leq 20^\circ
\end{cases}
\]
where \(Q\) is the critical runoff at a certain section (in cubic meters per second), \(d\) is the river channel width (in meters), and other parameters are the same as above.

### Results and Discussions
- **Changes in Debris Flow Source Materials**: Through aerial photos in different years and on - site investigations, the study found that the changes in the area of landslides and vegetation cover after the Wenchuan earthquake significantly affected the supply of debris flow source materials. Vegetation restoration reduced the potential debris flow source materials, and the area of landslides gradually decreased.
- **Changes in Critical Conditions**: The study found that as vegetation restoration and the reduction of source materials, the critical runoff and rainfall conditions for the formation of debris flows/floods increased year by year. This indicates that over time, the triggering conditions for debris flows/floods in this area have become more stringent.
- **Model Verification**: The accuracy of the model was verified by actual monitoring data, and the results showed that the model has a high prediction efficiency.

### Conclusions
This study successfully evaluated the critical conditions for the formation of debris flows/floods on the watershed scale in the Wenchuan earthquake - stricken area and their changing trends over time through comprehensive hydrological simulation and empirical models. The research results provide an important scientific basis for disaster prediction and risk management in this area.