Abstract:We examine the convective core helium burning phase of intermediate mass stars, and investigate the role of coupling of nuclear burning and mixing on the extension and duration of the blue loop phase. We compare the theoretical scenario with the distribution of stars in the colour-magnitude (CM) diagram of the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) cluster NGC1866, whose largely populated clump of He-burning stars is equally populated in the blue and red side. We compare the distributions expected by adopting either a diffusive scheme within the instability regions, in which nuclear burning and mixing are self-consistently coupled, or the traditional instantaneous mixing approximation. We analyze with particular care the sensitivity of the results to: a) the e-folding distance with which the velocity of convective eddies decays outside the formal border of the convective regions fixed by the Schwarzschild criterion; b) the convective model adopted to evaluate the temperature gradient; c) the rate of reaction C12+alpha -> O16. Models not including convective overshoot are also commented.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **To study the influence of the coupling of nuclear burning and mixing processes during the convective core helium - burning stage on the expansion and duration of the blue loop phase, and by comparing theoretical models with the distribution of stars in the color - magnitude diagram (CM diagram) in the NGC1866 cluster in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), to explore the influence of different mixing schemes on the residence time of helium - burning stars in the blue and red regions.** Specifically, the authors focus on: 1. **Coupling of nuclear burning and mixing processes**: To study how these two processes influence each other, especially during the helium - burning stage in the convective core region of stars. 2. **Characteristics of the blue loop phase**: To explore the influence of these processes on the expansion and duration of the blue loop phase (the phenomenon that stars move towards the blue region during their evolution). 3. **Observation data in the NGC1866 cluster**: By comparing the theoretical model predictions with the actually observed distribution of stars in the color - magnitude diagram in the NGC1866 cluster, to verify the effectiveness of different mixing schemes. ### Detailed description of key issues #### 1. Coupling of nuclear burning and mixing processes The authors compared two methods of dealing with nuclear burning and mixing: - **Instantaneous mixing approximation**: It is assumed that convection is very fast, so that a uniform chemical composition is always maintained throughout the unstable region. - **Diffusive approach**: It takes into account the self - consistent coupling of nuclear burning and mixing processes and uses the diffusion equation to describe the transport of elements. #### 2. Characteristics of the blue loop phase The blue loop phase refers to the phenomenon that stars move towards the blue region during their evolution. The authors pay special attention to: - **Expansion and duration of the blue loop phase**: This is determined by the coupling of nuclear burning and mixing processes. - **End of the blue loop phase**: When the central helium abundance drops to a certain level, the core begins to contract and the star returns to the red region. #### 3. Observation data in the NGC1866 cluster NGC1866 is a young cluster containing a large number of stars in the helium - burning stage. The authors use the observation data of this cluster to verify their theoretical models. Specifically: - **Distribution in the color - magnitude diagram**: The ratio of the number of stars in the blue and red regions (B/R) observed is close to 1, which provides an important constraint for the model. - **Synthetic color - magnitude diagram**: By simulating to generate a synthetic color - magnitude diagram and comparing it with the observation data to evaluate the effects of different mixing schemes. ### Main conclusions The authors found that when using the diffusive approach to deal with nuclear burning and mixing processes, stars stay longer in the blue loop phase (about 7 Myr), while under the instantaneous mixing approximation, the residence time is shorter (about 3 Myr). This indicates that the diffusive approach can better explain the phenomenon that the ratio of the number of stars in the blue and red regions observed in NGC1866 is close to 1. In addition, the authors also explored the influence of other factors (such as the distance of convective velocity attenuation, the choice of convection model, the 12C + α→16O reaction rate, etc.) on the results, further verifying the effectiveness of the diffusive approach. In general, through detailed theoretical calculations and the comparison of observation data, this paper reveals the important influence of the coupling of nuclear burning and mixing processes on star evolution, especially in the performance of the blue loop phase.

Time dependent mixing in He-burning cores: the case of NGC1866

The Effect of Nuclear Reaction Rates & Convective Mixing on the Evolution of a 6M$_{\odot}$ Star

3D hydrodynamics simulations of a 3 $M_{\odot}$ core-helium burning star

Atomic Diffusion and Mixing in Old Stars. III. Analysis of NGC 6397 Stars under New Constraints

Impact of central mixing scheme and nuclear reaction network on the extent of convective cores

Chemical mixing by turbulent convection in the overshooting region below the convective envelope of RGB stars

Convective boundary mixing in main-sequence stars: theory and empirical constraints

Constraining mixing processes in stellar cores using asteroseismology. Impact of semiconvection in low-mass stars

NGC 1866: a workbench for stellar evolution

Compulsory Deep Mixing of 3He and CNO Isotopes in the Envelopes of low-mass Red Giants

Mixed-mode coupling in the Red Clump I. Standard single star models

3D hydrodynamic simulations of massive main-sequence stars. I. Dynamics and mixing of convection and internal gravity waves

Core-Envelope Coupling in Intermediate-Mass Core-Helium Burning Stars

Helium Mixing in Globular Cluster Stars

Rayleigh-Taylor finger instability mixing in hydrodynamic shell convection models

A combined study of thermohaline mixing and envelope overshooting with PARSEC: Calibration to NGC 6397 and M4

3D simulations of convective shell Neon-burning in a massive star

The impact of asteroseismically calibrated internal mixing on nucleosynthetic wind yields of massive stars

The chemical composition of White Dwarfs as a test of convective efficiency during core He-burning

Mixing of materials in magnetised core-collapse supernova remnants