Reduced Visibility of Rabi Oscillations in Superconducting Qubits

Florian Meier,Daniel Loss

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.71.094519

2004-08-27

Abstract:Coherent Rabi oscillations between quantum states of superconducting micro-circuits have been observed in a number of experiments, albeit with a visibility which is typically much smaller than unity. Here, we show that the coherent coupling to background charge fluctuators [R.W. Simmonds et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 077003 (2004)] leads to a significantly reduced visibility if the Rabi frequency is comparable to the coupling energy of micro-circuit and fluctuator. For larger Rabi frequencies, transitions to the second excited state of the superconducting micro-circuit become dominant in suppressing the Rabi oscillation visibility. We also calculate the probability for Bogoliubov quasi-particle excitations in typical Rabi oscillation experiments.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Why is the visibility of Rabi oscillations observed in superconducting qubits (squbits for short) usually much lower than 1? Specifically, even in the case of a short decoherence time, the visibility of Rabi oscillations observed in experiments is significantly lower than theoretically expected.

### Main problems
1. **Low visibility of Rabi oscillations**: The visibility of Rabi oscillations observed in experiments is usually much lower than 1, even in a short time. For example, the visibility in some experiments is only 10% or 50%, indicating that there is some mechanism that causes a significant reduction in visibility.

2. **Possible reasons**: The paper explores three mechanisms that may cause the reduction in the visibility of Rabi oscillations:
- **Coherent coupling of background charge fluctuators**: When the Rabi frequency is comparable to the squbit - fluctuator coupling energy, this coupling will cause a significant reduction in visibility.
- **High - excited - state occupation caused by a strong driving field**: When the Rabi frequency is large, the system may transition to the second excited state, thereby suppressing the visibility of Rabi oscillations.
- **Bogoliubov quasiparticle excitation**: Bogoliubov quasiparticles may be excited during the experiment, which in turn affects the visibility of the system.

### Specific analysis
1. **Coherent coupling of background charge fluctuators**:
- The paper points out that when the Rabi frequency is comparable to the squbit - fluctuator coupling strength \( J \), the coherent coupling of fluctuators will cause a significant reduction in the visibility of the Rabi oscillation signal and a beating phenomenon will occur. For larger \( |b_x|/J \), the reduction in visibility can be described by the formula:
\[
p_1(t)\approx1 - \left(\frac{\pi J}{4 b_x}\right)^2
\]
This indicates that as \( b_x \) increases, the visibility will gradually recover to close to 1.

2. **High - excited - state occupation caused by a strong driving field**:
- When the Rabi frequency is large enough, the system may transition to the second excited state, causing a reduction in the visibility of Rabi oscillations. By considering the influence of the second excited state, the paper derives:
\[
p_1(t)=\left[1 - \frac{3}{2}\left(\frac{b_x}{2\hbar\Delta\omega}\right)^2\right]^2\sin^2\left(\frac{b_x t}{\hbar}\right)
\]
This indicates that the visibility will decrease quadratically as \( b_x \) increases.

3. **Bogoliubov quasiparticle excitation**:
- The excitation probability of quasiparticles is small in the zero - voltage state, but may increase under high - frequency driving. The paper calculates the excitation rate \( \Gamma \) of quasiparticles and finds that its influence on visibility is small, except under extreme conditions (such as a very high current pulse).

### Conclusion
Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, the paper explains the reasons for the reduction in the visibility of Rabi oscillations in superconducting qubits. The main conclusion is that the coherent coupling of background charge fluctuators and the high - excited - state occupation caused by a strong driving field are the main mechanisms that cause the reduction in visibility. In addition, although Bogoliubov quasiparticle excitation may also affect visibility in some cases, its effect is relatively small.

These results are helpful for understanding the decoherence mechanism in superconducting qubits and provide a theoretical basis for improving qubit performance in the future.