Applicability of self-consistent mean-field theory

Lu Guo,Fumihiko Sakata,Enguang Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.71.024315
2005-03-01
Abstract: Within the constrained Hartree-Fock (CHF) theory, an analytic condition is derived to estimate whether a concept of the self-consistent mean field is realized or not in level repulsive region. The derived condition states that an iterative calculation of CHF equation does not converge when the quantum fluctuations coming from two-body residual interaction and quadrupole deformation become larger than a single-particle energy difference between two avoided crossing orbits. By means of the numerical calculation, it is shown that the analytic condition works well for a realistic case.
Nuclear Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **The applicability of self - consistent mean - field theory in the level - repulsion region and its failure conditions**. Specifically, the paper explores the validity and limitations of the self - consistent Hartree - Fock (CHF) theory when energy levels are close to crossing (i.e., the level - repulsion region). Through analysis and numerical calculations, the author studies the competitive relationship between quantum fluctuations (from two - body residual interactions and quadrupole deformations) and single - particle energy differences, and derives an analytical condition to estimate whether the self - consistent mean - field can be achieved. This condition indicates that when quantum fluctuations exceed single - particle energy differences, the iterative calculation of the CHF equation will not converge, resulting in the failure of the self - consistent mean - field theory. ### The main problems of the paper can be summarized as follows: 1. **Applicability of self - consistent mean - field theory**: - Research the application range of self - consistent mean - field theory in the level - repulsion region. - Explore under what conditions the self - consistent mean - field theory is still valid and under what conditions it will fail. 2. **Influence of quantum fluctuations**: - Analyze the influence of quantum fluctuations (from two - body residual interactions and quadrupole deformations) on the self - consistent mean - field. - Research how these quantum fluctuations compete with single - particle energy differences and further affect the convergence of the CHF equation. 3. **Derivation of analytical conditions**: - Derive an analytical condition to estimate whether the self - consistent mean - field can be achieved in the level - repulsion region. - Verify the validity of this analytical condition through numerical calculations. 4. **Microscopic dynamic mechanism**: - Explore the microscopic dynamic mechanism of non - convergence phenomena in CHF iterative calculations. - Analyze how the interaction between two specific orbits leads to non - convergence in CHF calculations. ### Mathematical formula representation: The formulas involved in the paper include the CHF equation, Hamiltonian, density matrix, etc. Here are the Markdown - format representations of some key formulas: 1. **Nuclear Hamiltonian**: \[ \hat{H} = \sum_{\alpha\beta} t_{\alpha\beta} c^\dagger_\alpha c_\beta + \frac{1}{4} \sum_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} \bar{v}_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} c^\dagger_\alpha c^\dagger_\beta c_\delta c_\gamma \] 2. **CHF equation**: \[ \delta \left( \langle \Psi(q) | \hat{H} | \Psi(q) \rangle + \frac{1}{2} w \left( \langle \Psi(q) | \hat{Q}_{20} | \Psi(q) \rangle - \mu \right)^2 + \frac{1}{2} \alpha_x \langle \Psi(q) | \hat{x} | \Psi(q) \rangle^2 \right) = 0 \] 3. **Lagrange multiplier**: \[ \lambda(q) = w \left( \mu - \langle \Psi(q) | \hat{Q}_{20} | \Psi(q) \rangle \right) \] 4. **Analytical condition**: \[ \left\{ \frac{h^{(2)}_{A,A + 1}}{h^{(1)}_{A,A + 1}} \right\} \geq 0 \] Through these formulas and analyses, the paper aims to reveal the applicability and failure conditions of the self - consistent mean - field theory in the level - repulsion region, providing a theoretical basis for related research in nuclear structure physics.