To what extent does the self-consistent mean-field exist?

Lu Guo,Fumihiko Sakata,En-Guang Zhao,J. A. Maruhn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0218301306004739

2007-01-31

Abstract: A non-convergent difficulty near level-repulsive region is discussed within the self-consistent mean-field theory. It is shown by numerical and analytic studies that the mean-field is not realized in the many-fermion system when quantum fluctuations coming from two-body residual interaction and quadrupole deformation are larger than an energy difference between two avoided crossing orbits. An analytic condition indicating a limitation of the mean-field concept is derived for the first time.

Nuclear Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the non - convergence problem in self - consistent mean - field theory, especially when approaching the level - repulsion region. Specifically, the researchers explored whether the mean - field is still valid in a multi - fermion system when the quantum fluctuations (from two - body residual interactions and quadrupole deformations) are greater than the energy difference between two avoided - crossing orbits.

### Main problem description:

1. **Non - convergence difficulties**:
- In self - consistent Hartree - Fock (HF) calculations, especially when approaching the level - repulsion region, there are non - convergence difficulties. Even a slight change in the deformation variable may cause the calculation to not converge.

2. **Condition derivation**:
- Through numerical and analytical methods, the researchers first derived an analytical condition indicating under what circumstances the mean - field concept will fail. This condition reveals how the competition between the one - body potential and quantum fluctuations (mainly from two - body residual interactions) determines the existence of the mean - field.

### Specific problem formulation:

- **Analytical condition**: The researchers derived a condition, that is, the mean - field concept can be successfully applied only when the energy difference between two interacting orbits is not less than the quantum fluctuations caused by two - body residual interactions and quadrupole deformations. Expressed as a formula:
\[
\epsilon_{A + 1}(q_0)-\epsilon_A(q_0)\geq\bar{v}_{A + 1AAA + 1}+2wQ^2_{A,A + 1}+w\Delta\mu(Q_{A,A}-Q_{A + 1,A + 1})+O(b)
\]
where:
- \(\epsilon_A(q_0)\) and \(\epsilon_{A + 1}(q_0)\) are the energies of the two orbits respectively;
- \(\bar{v}_{A + 1AAA + 1}\) is the matrix element of the two - body residual interaction;
- \(Q_{A,A}\) and \(Q_{A + 1,A + 1}\) are the matrix elements of the deformation operator;
- \(O(b)\) contains the small mixing parameter \(b^{(1)}\).

### Conclusion:

- When the above condition is not satisfied, the self - consistent Hartree - Fock mean - field theory will fail when approaching the level - repulsion region. This conclusion has been verified through numerical simulations and analytical derivations, and it also explains why non - convergence phenomena occur in self - consistent calculations in some cases.

### Further research:

- The paper also discussed whether introducing "diagonalized" orbits or dynamic constraint operators based on the self - consistent collective coordinate method can alleviate this problem, but these issues still need further microscopic research to answer.

In summary, this paper aims to clearly point out, through an analytical condition, under what conditions the self - consistent mean - field theory will fail in the level - repulsion region, and provides theoretical and numerical evidence to support this conclusion.