Abstract:We propose that experiencing a lack of personal control will increase people's preferences for self-similar others and that this effect would be explained by a greater need for structure. Our hypotheses received support across 11 longitudinal, experimental, and archival studies composed of data from 60 countries (5 preregistered studies, N = 90,216). In an analysis of cross-country archival data, we found that respondents who indicated a lower sense of personal control were less likely to prefer to live with neighbors who had a different religion, race, or spoke a different language (Study 1). Study 2 found that participants who perceived lower (vs. higher) personal control indicated greater liking for coworkers who they perceived to be more self-similar across a wide range of characteristics (e.g., gender, personality). Studies 3a and 3b, two live-interaction experiments conducted in the United States and China, provided additional causal evidence for control-motivated similarity attraction. A causal experimental chain (Studies 4a to 4c) and a manipulation-of-mediation-as-a-moderator study (Study 5) provided evidence for the mediating effects of the need for structure. Study 6, a longitudinal study with Chinese employees, found that workers who reported perceiving a lower (vs. higher) sense of personal control preferred more self-similar coworkers, and this effect was mediated by a greater desire for structure. Finally, exploring downstream consequences, Studies 7a and 7b found that control-motivated similarity attraction was associated with a greater preference for homogenous (vs. diverse) groups. These findings highlight how the fundamental motive for personal control shapes the structure of social life.

To change, but not to preserve! Norm conformity following control threat only emerges for change norms but not for status quo norms

Control Deprivation and Styles of Thinking

When norm change hurts

This will not change us: Leader's use of continuity rhetoric to promote collective change

Agency Through the We: Group-Based Control Theory

What's in a norm? Sources and processes of norm change.

Norm Perception as a Vehicle for Social Change

Conformity and obedience

Social norm change: drivers and consequences

Bodies obliged and unbound: Differentiated response tendencies for injunctive and descriptive social norms.

Why social norms may fail us when we need them most

Understanding Norm Change: An Evolutionary Game-Theoretic Approach (Extended Version)

Collective action control: Ubiquitous processes and cultural differences

Do Human Assertions Really Adhere Strictly to Norms? The Effect of Threatening Content in Information on Personalized Norm Perception

Distinguishing fast change in social norms and slow change in personal norms in cooperative decision-making

Outrage towards whom? Threats to moral group status impede striving to improve via outgroup-directed outrage.

Threats to personal control fuel similarity attraction

Bottom-up influences on social norms: How observers' responses to transgressions drive norm maintenance versus change

Rethinking Norm Psychology

GROUP PRESSURE AND ACTION AGAINST A PERSON.

Adherence to Perceived Norms Across Cultural Boundaries: the Role of Need for Cognitive Closure and Ingroup Identification