Abstract:Importance Psychiatry mainly deals with conditions that are mediated by brain function but are not directly attributable to specific brain abnormalities. Given the lack of concrete biological markers, such as laboratory tests or imaging results, the development of diagnostic systems is difficult. Observations This narrative review evaluated 9 diagnostic approaches. The validity of the DSM and the International Classification of Disorders ( ICD ) is limited. The Research Domain Criteria is a research framework, not a diagnostic system. The clinical utility of the quantitatively derived, dimensional Hierarchical Taxonomy of Psychopathology is questionable. The Psychodynamic Diagnostic Manual Version 2 follows psychoanalytic theory and focuses on personality. Unlike the personality assessments in ICD-11 or DSM-5 ’s alternative model, based on pathological extremes of the big 5 traits (extraversion, agreeableness, openness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism), it lacks foundation in empirical evidence. Network analytic approaches are intriguing, but their complexity makes them difficult to implement. Staging would be easier if individually predictive biological markers were available. The problem with all these new approaches is that they abstract patient experiences into higher-order constructs, potentially obscuring individual symptoms so much that they no longer reflect patients’ actual problems. Conclusions and Relevance ICD and DSM diagnoses can be questioned, but the reality of psychopathological symptoms, such as hallucinations, depression, anxiety, compulsions, and the suffering stemming from them, cannot. Therefore, it may be advisable to primarily describe patients according to the psychopathological symptoms they present, and any resulting personal syndromes, embedded in a framework of contextual clinical characterization including personality assessment and staging. The DSM and ICD are necessary for reimbursement, but they should be simplified and merged. A primarily psychopathological symptoms–based, clinical characterization approach would be multidimensional and clinically useful, because it would lead to problem-oriented treatment and support transdiagnostic research. It should be based on a universally used instrument to assess psychopathology and structured clinical characterization.

Comorbidity (Psycho) Analysed

Comorbidity: A network perspective

Controversies in the contemporary understanding of comorbidity in psychiatry

Accepting multiple conditions in psychiatry: From comorbidity to multimorbidity

Revealing the Impact of Psychiatric Comorbidities on Treatment Outcome in Early Psychosis Using Counterfactual Model Explanation

Focusing on Comorbidity—A Novel Meta-Analytic Approach and Protocol to Disentangle the Specific Neuroanatomy of Co-occurring Mental Disorders

Editorial: Comorbidity in patients with psychiatric disorders: Epidemiological and molecular perspectives

Response: Comorbidity of Epilepsy

Conceptualising comorbidity and multimorbidity in dementia: A scoping review and syndemic framework

Recent advances in the study of the comorbidity of depressive and anxiety disorders.

PSYCHIATRIC COMORBIDITY DOES NOT ONLY DEPEND ON DIAGNOSTIC THRESHOLDS: AN ILLUSTRATION WITH MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER AND GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER

Comorbidity in the Dutch Twin Study on Bipolar Disorder: Challenge or Methodological Problem?

Physical comorbidities in people with severe mental disorders: promises and future challenges

The anatomy of co-morbid neuropsychiatric disorders based on cortico-limbic synaptic interactions

Are comorbidities compatible with a molecular pathological classification of neurodegenerative diseases?

Age, Comorbidity, Frailty in Observational and Analytic Studies of Neurological Diseases

Analysis and Design of Systems to Classify the Concepts of Comorbidity

Comorbidity and Its Impact on Disability

Prioritization of Psychopathological Symptoms and Clinical Characterization in Psychiatric Diagnoses

A pilot study of new approaches to exploring illness trajectories and patterns of comorbidity in major mental disorders

Comorbidity and Anticomorbidity: Autocognitive developmental disorders of structured psychosocial stress