Characterization and Analysis of Corrosion Resistance of Rubber Materials for Downhole Tools in a High-Stress Environment with Coupled H2S-CO2

Leilei Gong,Yulin Chen,Meng Cai,Junliang Li,Qiuyu Lu,Duo Hou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ma17040863

IF: 3.4

2024-02-13

Materials

Abstract:In the process of constructing deep natural gas wells in Sichuan and Chongqing, gas wells encounter various technical challenges such as high temperature, high pressure, and a corrosive environment containing H2S and CO2. The corrosion of rubber materials in these acidic environments can easily lead to seal failure in downhole tools. To better investigate the corrosion resistance of rubber materials in acidic environments, we utilized a dynamic cyclic corrosion experimental device capable of simulating the service conditions experienced by downhole tools under high-temperature, high-pressure multiphase flow. Corrosion-resistance tests were conducted on fluororubbers (FKM) 1, 2, 3, and HNBR (hydrogenated nitrile-butadiene rubber) under acidic conditions (80 °C and 160 °C), along with sealing corrosion tests on O-rings. These tests aimed to analyze the mechanical properties, hardness, and corrosion resistance before and after exposure to acid media as well as the sealing performance of O-rings. Ultimately, our goal was to identify suitable rubber materials for acidic pressure environments. Experimental results revealed that all four types of rubber exhibited decreased elongation at break after undergoing corrosion testing; however, fluororubber 3 demonstrated significant susceptibility to temperature effects while the other three types showed minimal impact from temperature variations. Fluororubber 1 and fluororubber 3 displayed substantial deformation levels whereas mechanical properties greatly deteriorated for fluororubber 2. Overall, HNBR showcased superior comprehensive performance.

materials science, multidisciplinary,chemistry, physical,physics, applied, condensed matter,metallurgy & metallurgical engineering

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the corrosion - resistance performance of rubber materials (especially those used for down - hole tools) in a corrosive environment with high temperature, high pressure, H₂S and CO₂. Specifically, the research aims to:

1. **Evaluate the corrosion - resistance performance of rubber materials in an acidic environment**: By simulating the high - temperature, high - pressure multiphase - flow conditions experienced by actual down - hole tools, test the corrosion - resistance performance of fluoroelastomers (FKM 1, FKM 2, FKM 3) and hydrogenated nitrile - butadiene rubber (HNBR) at 80°C and 160°C.

2. **Analyze the changes in the mechanical properties of rubber materials**: Study the changes in the mechanical properties (such as hardness, tensile strength and elongation at break) and sealing performance of these rubber materials before and after corrosion.

3. **Determine rubber materials suitable for acidic pressure environments**: Through comparative experiments on different types of rubber materials, find the rubber materials that perform best in high - temperature, high - pressure acidic environments to ensure their reliability and safety in practical applications.

### Specific Objectives

- **Identify rubber materials suitable for acidic pressure environments**: Through experimental verification, find rubber materials that can maintain good mechanical properties and sealing performance under high - temperature, high - pressure acidic conditions.
- **Provide theoretical basis and technical support**: Provide reference values and theoretical basis for selecting appropriate rubber cylinders and sealing rings, thereby ensuring the safe production of oil and gas wells and reducing production costs.

### Experimental Methods

To achieve the above objectives, the researchers used a dynamic cyclic corrosion experimental device to simulate the working environment of down - hole tools under high - temperature, high - pressure multiphase - flow conditions and carried out the following experiments:

1. **Corrosion experiment**: Conducted corrosion tests on four rubber materials (FKM 1, FKM 2, FKM 3, HNBR) at temperature conditions of 80°C and 160°C.
2. **Sealing performance experiment**: Conducted a sealing corrosion test on O - rings and observed their deformation characteristics after corrosion.
3. **Mechanical property test**: Used an optical microscope, a rubber tensile testing machine and a Shore hardness tester to analyze the mechanical properties and macroscopic morphology of rubber samples.

### Results and Conclusions

The experimental results show that the elongation at break of all four rubber materials decreased after the corrosion test, but the performance of different materials differed significantly:

- **Fluororubber 3** is very sensitive to temperature changes and shows a significant temperature effect.
- **Fluororubber 1 and Fluororubber 3** show a large deformation level.
- **Fluororubber 2** has a significant decrease in mechanical properties.
- **HNBR** exhibits superior comprehensive properties and shows good elastic characteristics and stability in high - temperature, high - pressure acidic environments.

In conclusion, this research provides important experimental data and theoretical support for selecting rubber materials suitable for high - temperature, high - pressure acidic environments.